SCENARIO 4: THE SILENT EXIT
A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW
Scenario Title | The Silent Exit |
Module Association | Module 1 – Emotional Intelligence in Youth Work |
Module Theme | Emotional awareness, silent withdrawal, inclusion and participation equity in group work |
Competences Developed | Emotional awareness; empathy; inclusion; teamwork; active listening; peer support |
Target Group | Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training |
Recommended Age Category | 15–18 and 18–21 |
Duration | 10–20 minutes for role-play; 15–20 minutes for debrief |
Difficulty Level | Introductory / Intermediate |
Format | Face-to-face, online or blended |
Training Objectives

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION
During a youth workshop, participants are working in small groups to develop ideas for a social media campaign.
One participant, Ana, suggests interviewing local market vendors and including real community voices in the campaign.
Her idea is not rejected directly, but it is ignored as the more confident participants continue discussing their own ideas.
Ana slowly becomes quieter, stops contributing and eventually leaves the room without explaining why.
Luca, who has been leading the brainstorming with high energy, is surprised and confused.
Maya, another participant, notices that Ana had been withdrawing before she left and begins to question how inclusive the group process really was.
The scenario explores how exclusion can happen without bad intentions, how silence can communicate emotional discomfort, and how peers can become more aware of participation dynamics.
C. ROLES
ROLE 1: ANA
Profile of the Character
A creative but less assertive participant. She is new to the group and has experienced being overlooked before.
Emotional State
Disappointed, hurt, invisible, withdrawn.
Motivation
She wants to contribute meaningfully to the campaign.
Goal / Hidden Intention
She wants to feel seen and valued, but does not want to fight for attention or risk rejection.
ROLE 2: LUCA
Profile of the Character
An enthusiastic and extroverted participant. He enjoys brainstorming and often takes up a lot of space in group discussions.
Emotional State
Energised, focused, unaware; later confused and regretful.
Motivation
He wants the group to create a strong and exciting campaign idea.
Goal / Hidden Intention
He does not intend to exclude Ana, but he is more focused on speed and energy than on equal participation.
ROLE 3: MAYA
Profile of the Character
An observant participant who is sensitive to group dynamics. She notices non-verbal cues but is unsure when to intervene.
Emotional State
Uncertain, concerned, empathetic.
Motivation
She wants the group to work well together and include everyone.
Goal / Hidden Intention
She wants to address the situation without blaming Luca or making Ana feel more exposed.
D. ACTIVITY FLOW
STEP 1: PREPARATION
Facilitation / Activity Step: Explain the context and distribute role cards. Ask participants to pay attention to silence, posture, eye contact and participation patterns.
Time: 5 minutes
Notes for Facilitator: Emphasise that the scenario is about unintentional exclusion, not obvious bullying.
STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY
Facilitation / Activity Step: Participants act out the brainstorming session. Ana should try to contribute once, then gradually withdraw. Luca continues with enthusiasm. Maya notices the change.
Time: 10–15 minutes
Notes for Facilitator: Encourage realistic pacing. Ana's withdrawal should be subtle at first.
STEP 3: OBSERVATION
Facilitation / Activity Step: Optional observers track who speaks, whose ideas are acknowledged, body language, and the moment when Ana emotionally disconnects.
Time: During role-play
Notes for Facilitator: Observers can use a simple participation map or tally speaking turns.
STEP 4: DEBRIEF / REFLECTION
Facilitation / Activity Step: Facilitate discussion using the reflection questions.
Time: 15–20 minutes
Notes for Facilitator: Focus on emotional cues, group responsibility, overlooked ideas and inclusive facilitation.
STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE
Facilitation / Activity Step: Ask participants to develop 3–5 rules for inclusive brainstorming.
Time: 5–10 minutes
Notes for Facilitator: Example: "Acknowledge each idea before moving on"; "Invite quieter voices without pressure."

E. SUGGESTED ROLE-PLAY SCRIPT
Setting: A creative workshop room. Flipcharts and markers are on the tables. The team is brainstorming ideas for a social media campaign. Ana sits quietly with a notebook. Luca is standing near the flipchart, full of energy. Maya is seated nearby, listening.
Luca, gesturing toward the flipchart:
"Okay, so we have the 'Zero Waste Week' idea: seven days, seven tips. I love it. Maybe we do short videos too."
Maya, smiling:
"That could work. Like short reels with voiceovers?"
Luca, excited:
"Exactly. I can bring my tripod tomorrow. And Maya, your editing skills would be perfect for this."
Ana looks at her notes and clears her throat softly.
Ana, carefully:
"We could also interview local market vendors. Like real voices from the community?"
There is a brief pause. Luca does not respond directly and continues writing on the board.
Luca:
"And maybe we make it into a challenge. Like 'challenge accepted' content. More interactive."
Ana looks down. Her shoulders drop slightly. She closes her notebook halfway. Maya glances at her but says nothing.
A few minutes pass. Luca and Maya continue discussing video ideas. Ana stops writing and looks toward the door.
Ana, quietly, standing up:
"I'm just going to get some air."
Maya, noticing:
"Hey Ana, are you okay?"
Ana, avoiding eye contact:
"Yeah. I'm fine."
Ana leaves the room.
Luca, confused:
"Did something happen?"
Maya, softly:
"I think we missed her idea. She looked really shut down after that."
Luca, defensive at first:
"What? I wasn't ignoring her. I just didn't hear it properly."
Maya:
"That's kind of the point. We were moving fast, and we didn't leave space."
Luca pauses and looks at the flipchart.
Luca, regretful:
"You're right. Her idea was actually good. Should we check on her?"
Maya:
"Yes. And next time, maybe we slow down and make sure every idea is acknowledged."
The group prepares to speak with Ana and rethink how they manage the brainstorming process.
F. REFLECTION QUESTIONS
What signs showed that Ana was feeling excluded or overlooked?
How could the group have responded differently when Ana shared her idea?
Why might someone leave silently instead of saying they feel hurt?
What responsibility do peers have when they notice someone withdrawing?
How can youth workers make brainstorming activities more inclusive?
What practical rules can help groups make space for quieter participants?
G. MATERIALS NEEDED
- Printed or digital role cards
- Flipchart or digital whiteboard
- Markers, post-its or online sticky notes
- Optional campaign prompt sheet
- Observer sheet for participation and emotional cues
- Timer
H. ADAPTATION NOTES
Adaptation for Different Groups
For younger participants, focus on the basic idea of noticing when someone is left out.
For older participants, add deeper reflection on group power dynamics, confidence, social status and emotional safety.
Cultural / Local Adaptation
Adapt the campaign topic to the local context, such as environmental action, youth participation, mental health awareness, volunteering, cultural events or community safety.
Character names and examples can also be adapted.
Accessibility Considerations
Provide clear role cards and allow participants to choose observer roles.
Use visual participation tools, such as speaking tokens or idea cards, to support participants who need more time before speaking.
Avoid pressuring quiet participants to explain personal experiences.
Online Delivery Version
The scenario can take place in an online workshop.
Ana may write her idea in the chat and it is ignored, or she may turn off her camera after being overlooked.
Observers can track who speaks, whose chat messages are acknowledged and when participants disengage.
A shared digital board can be used to create inclusive brainstorming rules.
