SCENARIO 1 – THE MISSED SIGNAL
A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW
Scenario Title | The Missed Signal |
Module Association | Module 2 – Role-Playing and Emotional Communication |
Module Theme | Active listening, non-verbal communication, empathetic responses and repairing misunderstandings |
Competences Developed | Active listening; empathy; emotional regulation; constructive communication; conflict resolution; perspective-taking |
Target Group | Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training |
Duration | 10–20 minutes for role-play; 15–20 minutes for debrief |
Difficulty Level | Intermediate |
Format | Face-to-face, online or blended |
Learning Objectives

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION
Three friends and youth group members, Alex, Jamie and Taylor, are planning a community event.
Alex is an energetic, task-focused leader who wants to keep things moving.
Jamie, who is usually reliable, has recently been unusually quiet and withdrawn, giving short answers and avoiding eye contact.
Taylor is perceptive and values team harmony. They notice the growing tension between Alex and Jamie.
As Alex's frustration boils over into a sharp accusation, Jamie shuts down completely.
Taylor must decide whether to intervene and how to help both friends communicate.
The scenario explores how missed emotional signals, unspoken personal stress and defensive communication can damage relationships, and how active listening and empathy can repair them.
C. ROLES
ROLE 1: ALEX
Profile of the Character
A passionate and task-oriented group member who usually drives projects forward. They take pride in their work and expect the same level of commitment from others.
Emotional State
Frustrated, impatient and feeling let down. Alex interprets Jamie's silence as laziness or a lack of care.
Motivation
Alex wants to complete the project on time and to a high standard. They also want to feel supported by their teammates.
Goal / Hidden Intention
Alex wants Jamie to contribute and share the workload. However, Alex expresses their frustration through sarcasm and blame, which pushes Jamie further away and makes the situation worse.
ROLE 2: JAMIE
Profile of the Character
A usually thoughtful and dependable group member who is currently overwhelmed by a stressful personal situation at home that they have not shared.
Emotional State
Overwhelmed, anxious, withdrawn and ashamed. Jamie feels judged and is beginning to shut down completely.
Motivation
Jamie wants to avoid talking about their personal problems. They also want to fulfil their responsibilities without having to explain themselves.
Goal / Hidden Intention
Jamie wants to protect themselves from judgement and avoid revealing their personal struggles. Their silence acts as a shield, but Alex misinterprets it as apathy. Jamie wants to be left alone to cope privately.
ROLE 3: TAYLOR
Profile of the Character
An observant and emotionally intelligent group member who values team cohesion. They notice subtle changes in people's moods and behaviour.
Emotional State
Concerned, conflicted and careful. Taylor senses that something is wrong with Jamie but does not want to overstep or make the situation uncomfortable.
Motivation
Taylor wants to keep the team working well together and prevent the conflict from damaging the project or their friendships.
Goal / Hidden Intention
Taylor wants to help Alex and Jamie understand each other without taking sides or escalating the tension. They want to create a space where Jamie feels safe enough to open up and where Alex also feels heard.
D. ACTIVITY FLOW – Scenario 1
STEP 1: PREPARATION
Facilitation / Activity Step
Explain the scenario and distribute the role cards.
Give participants a few minutes to read their roles and think about their character's emotional state, posture and tone of voice.
Remind participants that the goal is to explore communication dynamics, not to "win" the argument.
Time: 5 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Emphasise that the scenario focuses on the breakdown and repair of communication.
Alex should not be portrayed as a bully, but as someone who is stressed and does not know how to ask for help.
Jamie should not be portrayed as lazy, but as someone who is struggling silently.
Taylor should not be portrayed as a superhero who immediately solves everything, but as someone who is unsure how to help.
STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY
Facilitation / Activity Step
Participants act out the planning session.
The scene should begin with Alex trying to move the work forward, Jamie responding with silence or short answers and Taylor observing.
The tension should gradually build until Alex makes an accusatory or sarcastic remark.
Taylor must then decide when and how to intervene.
Time: 10–15 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Encourage participants to allow the tension to develop naturally.
The turning point is important. This is the moment when Taylor or Alex must change their communication approach.
Allow the scene to have an open ending.
STEP 3: OBSERVATION
Facilitation / Activity Step
Optional observers note non-verbal cues, including body language, eye contact and tone of voice.
They should also note moments of escalation, such as sarcasm or blame, and the moment when the communication begins to change.
Time: During the role-play
Notes for Facilitator
Observers can use a simple sheet with three questions:
- "What was said?"
- "What did the body language communicate?"
- "What emotion did it show?"
STEP 4: DEBRIEF / REFLECTION
Facilitation / Activity Step
Facilitate a group discussion using the reflection questions.
Focus on the difference between hearing and listening, the impact of non-verbal communication and how empathy can change the outcome of a difficult conversation.
Time: 15–20 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Guide the discussion from "What happened?" towards "What could have been done differently?"
Pay particular attention to Taylor's role as an observer and intervener.
STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE
Facilitation / Activity Step
Ask participants to create a short "Communication Checklist" for youth projects.
This could include principles such as:
- "Check in with teammates before making assumptions."
- "Use 'I' statements."
- "Ask open-ended questions to understand."
Time: 5–10 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Encourage participants to consider how they can apply these insights in their own group work, youth activities and personal lives.
E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS
F. MATERIALS NEEDED
- Printed or digital role cards
- A table and chairs arranged in a small triangle or semicircle
- Optional observer sheet for tracking non-verbal cues
- Pens and paper for note-taking
- Timer
G. ADAPTATION NOTES – Scenario 1
Adaptation for Different Groups
For younger participants aged 15–16, simplify the personal stressor.
Jamie could be worried about an upcoming examination or experiencing a disagreement with a friend.
For older participants aged 19–21, make the scenario more complex by introducing a higher-stakes project, such as a presentation to a funder.
The discussion can also explore the ethical responsibility of a team leader to check in with team members.
Cultural / Local Adaptation
Adapt the names, the nature of the project and the personal stressor to the local context.
The project could involve:
- a school event;
- a sports activity;
- a cultural festival;
- a community campaign;
- a volunteering initiative.
The personal stressor can reflect locally relevant challenges, such as family expectations, part-time work, university application anxiety or caring responsibilities.
Accessibility Considerations
Provide clear and concise role cards with the key emotional states highlighted.
Allow participants to observe instead of acting if they do not feel comfortable taking part in the role-play.
Participants who find it difficult to express emotions verbally can focus on posture, eye contact, facial expression and other non-verbal cues.
Introduce a clear "pause" signal, such as raising a hand, which any participant can use if the role-play becomes too intense.
Online Delivery Version
This scenario can be delivered through a video call.
The limited physical presence can become part of the learning activity.
Ask participants: "How do we recognise emotions when we can only see someone's face on a screen?"
The turning point could happen when Alex notices a change in Jamie's facial expression or when Taylor sends Jamie a private supportive message before speaking to the whole group.
The role-play can take place in a breakout room.
The debrief can be held in the main meeting room or through a collaborative digital board where participants can contribute anonymous written reflections.
The Communication Checklist can be created in a shared online document.
