EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 04

Civic Engagement

Explore participation, community responsibility, dialogue and decision-making through scenarios connected with civic action and active citizenship.

Module 4 was developed by BIV, Türkiye, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 1 / 5

SCENARIO 1

WHO GETS THE PARK?

FROM COMPLAINTS TO CIVIC ACTION

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

Who Gets the Park? From Complaints to Civic Action

Module Association

Module 4 – Civic Engagement

Competences Developed

Civic responsibility and participation; empathy and perspective-taking; inclusive communication and conflict sensitivity; teamwork and shared decision-making; basic leadership through proposing and negotiating actions

Target Group

Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

Approximately 15 minutes

Format

Face-to-face or blended

Learning Objectives

Identify at least two constructive ways young people can raise a local issue with public authorities.
Practise active listening and respectful dialogue with stakeholders who have different interests.
Explore how to move from complaining to proposing a simple and realistic civic action.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION

A group of young people often spend time in a small local park after school.

Recently, the park has become dirty, several benches are broken and the lighting is poor.

Young people feel unsafe at night and complain that "no one cares about us".

At the same time, some adult neighbours complain about noise and rubbish and want stricter rules instead of more youth activities.

The municipality has invited representatives to a short meeting at the youth centre to discuss the situation in the park.

A youth worker is trying to help both sides speak and listen to one another.

The group must decide whether the meeting will remain focused on complaints and blame, or whether they can agree on one small, concrete action to improve the park together.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: LUCA

Age and Role: 17-year-old active young person

Profile: Luca is a skater who spends a lot of time in the park with friends.

Emotional State and Motivation: Luca feels ignored and disrespected by adults. He is angry that the park is unsafe and dirty. He wants better lighting and would also like a skate ramp.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Luca wants adults to finally listen and do something. He is ready to help, but easily becomes defensive and sarcastic when he feels blamed.

ROLE 2: MRS LULIA

Age and Role: 55-year-old neighbour and parent

Profile: Mrs Lulia lives next to the park and has a ten-year-old child.

Emotional State and Motivation: She is worried about noise, broken glass and groups of young people staying late. She is afraid for her child's safety.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Mrs Lulia wants stricter rules and possibly a closing time. She is unsure whether young people can behave responsibly, but may change her view if she feels heard and sees young people taking responsibility.

ROLE 3: MR JONAS

Age and Role: 38-year-old municipal youth officer

Profile: Mr Jonas works for the municipality and is responsible for youth issues and public spaces.

Emotional State and Motivation: He is tired of complaints from all sides. He has limited time and budget and wants a quick solution that reduces conflict.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Mr Jonas wants to show that he is doing his job without making promises he cannot keep. He is open to youth-led initiatives if they appear realistic and affordable.

ROLE 4: ALI

Age and Role: 28-year-old youth worker and facilitator

Profile: Ali works at the local youth centre. He knows both the young people and several neighbours.

Emotional State and Motivation: Ali wants dialogue rather than conflict. He believes young people can take responsibility when they are trusted.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Ali hopes the meeting will end with at least one small joint action, such as a clean-up day or a petition for improved lighting, which all parties can support.

D. SUGGESTED ROLE-PLAY SCRIPT

Setting: Ali stands in the small meeting room of the youth centre. Four chairs form a circle. Luca sits with his arms crossed, looking at the floor. Mrs Lulia keeps her bag on her lap and looks tense. Mr Jonas scrolls quickly on his phone, then puts it away with a sigh.

Ali: "Thank you all for coming. I know everyone is busy. We are here to talk about the park and see whether we can find one small step forward together. Maybe we can start with how each of you sees the problem. Luca, would you like to begin?"

Luca, shrugging and speaking loudly: "Yeah… For me, the park is the only place to hang out with my friends after school. But it is getting worse every week. The benches are broken, there is no light and sometimes strange people come at night. We do not feel safe, but everyone blames us as if it is our fault."

Mrs Lulia, frowning slightly: "Well, sometimes it is noisy, Luca. I live next to the park. At eleven or midnight, I still hear shouting and music. My ten-year-old son cannot sleep. In the morning, there is rubbish and broken glass. I am scared for him."

Luca, defensive and leaning forward: "We do not break the glass! Other people come too. But when adults see young people, they always think we are the problem."

Ali, raising a hand gently: "Let us slow down for a second. Luca, I hear that you feel blamed and unsafe. Mrs Lulia, I hear that you feel tired and worried about your child. You both care about the park, right?"

Both nod reluctantly.

Ali: "Okay. Mr Jonas, could you share the municipality's point of view?"

Mr Jonas, straightening his back: "We receive many emails about this park. Noise, rubbish, broken benches and poor lighting. But we also have a limited budget and many parks to maintain. We cannot fix everything at once. To be honest, it sometimes feels as though people only complain and expect us to solve everything immediately."

Luca: "So nothing will change again?"

Mr Jonas: "I did not say that. But if you want something like a skate ramp or more lighting, we need a clear proposal and perhaps some help from the community. We cannot do it alone."

D. SUGGESTED ROLE-PLAY SCRIPT (continued)

Mrs Lulia: "A skate ramp? That will create even more noise."

Luca, rolling his eyes: "See? Adults never want us there."

Ali, gently: "Perhaps we can shift from asking who is guilty to asking what small action everyone could accept. Let me ask each of you: what is the one thing you most want for the park?"

Luca, thinking: "I want it to be clean and safe so we can stay there without trouble. A skate ramp would be great, but I know that is a big request."

Mrs Lulia: "I want my son to sleep and to walk through the park without fear. Less noise at night and no broken glass."

Mr Jonas: "I want fewer complaints and to show that the municipality listens, even with a small budget."

Ali: "So the common points are that everyone wants the park to be clean and safe. What small action could we take in the next month that would help with that?"

There is a short silence.

Luca: "We could organise a clean-up day. Not just us, but other young people too. If the park looks better, perhaps people will respect it more."

Mrs Lulia, surprised: "You would really do that?"

Luca: "Yes. But it cannot be only me and two friends. Maybe the youth centre can help?"

Ali, smiling: "We can definitely help. We can invite young people from the centre, prepare gloves and rubbish bags and perhaps make posters."

Mr Jonas: "If you organise a clean-up day and show that there is community support, I can ask the municipality to send a worker to repair at least one bench and inspect the lighting. I cannot promise everything, but I can try."

Mrs Lulia: "If I see young people taking responsibility, I can speak to some neighbours. We could bring snacks or tea and join the clean-up too. Regarding the noise, perhaps you could agree on a time to lower the music?"

Luca, nodding slowly: "Okay. We could make our own rule: after ten in the evening, no speakers, only talking. I can discuss it with my friends."

Ali: "This sounds like a real agreement. Let us make it concrete. Luca, what will you do?"

Luca: "I will speak to my friends and invite them. We can also make a simple poster or a social media post about the clean-up day."

Ali: "Great. Mrs Lulia?"

Mrs Lulia: "I will speak to my neighbours and ask who wants to join. I can also share the date in our building's WhatsApp group."

Ali: "And you, Mr Jonas?"

Mr Jonas: "I will check which date is suitable for a municipal worker to collect the rubbish bags and inspect the broken bench and lighting. If I receive approval, I will send a confirmation email this week."

Ali: "Perfect. I will provide support from the youth centre, help with materials and coordinate everyone."

Ali looks around the circle.

Ali: "Before we finish, one last question. How do you feel after this meeting?"

Luca: "A little less angry. I still think adults judge us too quickly, but this feels as though we are doing something rather than only being blamed."

Mrs Lulia: "I feel more hopeful. I can see that you care about the park, Luca. I did not know that before."

Mr Jonas: "I feel more motivated. When I see people ready to help, my job becomes easier."

Ali, smiling: "Then our first civic action has already begun. Thank you all. Let us keep this energy for the clean-up day."

E. INSTRUCTIONS FOR PARTICIPANTS

Read Your Role Card

Time: 3 minutes

Think about:

  • What do I want from this meeting?
  • What am I afraid of?
  • What sentence will I use as my opening statement?

Opening Round

Time: 2 minutes

Each role explains:

  • What is the problem with the park?
  • What do I want to change?

Discussion and Negotiation

Time: 5 minutes

All roles react to each other. Try to:

  • listen and reflect on what others say;
  • avoid blaming language;
  • suggest at least one specific and realistic action.

Decision

Time: 5 minutes

As a group, agree on one small civic action that can be completed during the next month. Possible actions include:

  • a joint clean-up day;
  • a letter or email to the municipality;
  • simple posters encouraging people to keep the park clean;
  • a petition for improved lighting.

Decide who will be responsible for each action.

F. FACILITATOR INSTRUCTIONS

Group Formation: Create groups of four participants and assign one role to each person. For larger groups, roles may be duplicated.

Briefing: Remind participants that the goal is to practise civic dialogue, not to win an argument. Establish the following ground rules:

  • listen actively;
  • avoid personal attacks;
  • speak from the perspective of the assigned role;
  • focus on practical solutions.

During the Role-Play, observe:

  • body language;
  • who speaks more and who speaks less;
  • how participants describe the problem;
  • whether the conversation remains focused on blame or shifts towards action.

If the discussion becomes stuck, pause and ask: "What is one thing you all care about?"

Keep track of time and guide the group towards the decision stage.

G. REFLECTION QUESTIONS

How did you feel in your role during the meeting?
What helped the group move from complaints to a concrete action (if you managed it)?
Where did you see empathy or active listening in the conversation? Where was it missing?
What could the youth worker or youth officer do differently to support youth participation more fairly?
In your real context, what small civic action could you start around a shared space (park, youth centre, school yard, etc.)?
(Optional extra) Whose voice was missing in this meeting (e.g. other young people, people with disabilities, migrants), and how could they be included next time?

H. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Printed or digital role cards
  • Flipchart or A3 paper
  • Markers
  • Timer or clock

I. ADAPTATION NOTES

Different Contexts

Replace the park with another shared space, such as:

  • a school canteen;
  • a youth club;
  • a sports field;
  • a community garden.

Younger Groups

For participants aged 15–17, shorten the discussion and provide two or three suggested actions from which they can choose.

Older Groups and Youth Workers

Ask participants to connect the agreed action to Module 4 tools such as:

  • stakeholder mapping;
  • problem trees;
  • SMART goals.

Online Delivery Version

Use breakout rooms and digital role cards. Participants can write their final civic action in a shared document, online board or collaborative workspace.