SCENARIO 1
NEW STUDENT, OLD BARRIERS
A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW
Scenario Title | New Student, Old Barriers |
Module Association | Module 3 – Soft Skills and Inclusion |
Module Theme | Soft skills, inclusion, empathy and recognising exclusion within peer groups |
Competences Developed | Empathy; inclusion; emotional regulation; active listening |
Target Group | Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training |
Duration | 10–20 minutes for role-play; approximately 10 minutes for debrief |
Difficulty Level | Intermediate |
Format | Face-to-face or blended |
Learning Objectives

SCENARIO 1
B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION
A new student, Amir, joins a secondary school group.
Amir comes from a returnee family and is perceived by some members of the group as "different" and unsure of himself.
During a group activity, participants are asked to work in pairs.
It soon becomes clear that nobody wants to choose Amir as their partner.
The facilitator eventually assigns the pairs, but the atmosphere becomes tense as Amir begins to feel rejected.
The situation explores how social exclusion can happen without direct insults or open conflict.
It also examines how hesitation, silence, body language and group choices can communicate rejection, and how one supportive action can help change the atmosphere.
C. ROLES
ROLE 1: AMIR
Profile: A quiet and insecure new student from a returnee family. Amir wants ordinary communication, acceptance and an opportunity to participate like everyone else.
Emotional State: Rejected, insecure and cautious.
Motivation: Amir wants to take part in the task and feel accepted by his peers.
Goal / Hidden Intention: Amir needs time and emotional safety before he feels comfortable speaking. He hopes that someone will notice his isolation and invite him to participate without making him feel like a problem.
ROLE 2: LENA
Profile: A confident and popular peer who is efficient and quick to judge, but not intentionally harmful.
Emotional State: Impatient and initially unaware; later reflective.
Motivation: Lena wants the task to be completed quickly and smoothly.
Goal / Hidden Intention: Lena does not initially recognise that her choices and body language exclude Amir. She assumes that choosing a familiar and confident partner is simply the most efficient option.
ROLE 3: MARKO
Profile: An observant group member who notices that Amir is being excluded but hesitates before intervening.
Emotional State: Concerned and hesitant.
Motivation: Marko wants the group to behave fairly without creating additional tension.
Goal / Hidden Intention: Marko wants to support Amir through a small but meaningful action. He must decide whether to remain silent, speak to Lena or directly invite Amir to join him.
D. ACTIVITY FLOW
STEP 1: PREPARATION
Facilitation / Activity Step: Introduce the context, explain the role-play task and distribute the role cards. Give participants time to read their roles and think about their character's emotional state, posture and behaviour.
Time: 3 minutes
Notes for Facilitator: Encourage realistic behaviour and avoid exaggerated dramatisation. Remind participants that exclusion may be communicated through silence, hesitation, eye contact, seating choices and body language rather than direct insults.
STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY
Facilitation / Activity Step: Participants act out the situation in which the group must form pairs. Amir waits to be chosen, Lena quickly chooses another participant and Marko notices what is happening. The role-play should continue until Marko decides whether and how to intervene.
Time: 8–12 minutes
Notes for Facilitator: Allow the exclusion or imbalance to emerge naturally. Do not force a quick resolution. The turning point should come from a realistic action by one of the participants.
STEP 3: OBSERVATION
Facilitation / Activity Step: Optional observers note communication patterns, body language, emotional cues and turning points.
Time: During the role-play
Notes for Facilitator: Observers should focus on: who makes eye contact with Amir; who avoids him; how participants choose their partners; when Amir begins to withdraw; what action begins to change the situation.
STEP 4: DEBRIEF / REFLECTION
Facilitation / Activity Step: Facilitate a group discussion using the reflection questions.
Time: 10 minutes
Notes for Facilitator: Explore the difference between intention and impact. Lena may not intend to exclude Amir, but her behaviour still affects him. Identify the moment when exclusion became visible and the action that could have changed the situation.
STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE
Facilitation / Activity Step: Connect the scenario to youth work, school projects, youth exchanges and other group activities. Ask participants to identify practical ways to include someone who is new, uncertain or isolated.
Time: 5 minutes
Notes for Facilitator: Ask each participant to name one inclusion strategy they can use in a real group setting. Examples may include: inviting someone to join; explaining the task clearly; checking whether everyone has a partner; introducing a new participant to others; allowing more time to respond.

E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS
F. MATERIALS NEEDED
- Printed or digital role descriptions
- Markers
- Coloured pencils
- A4 paper
- Flipchart or whiteboard
- Classroom or workshop room arranged for small-group work
- Timer
G. ADAPTATION NOTES
Adaptation for Different Groups: Adjust the complexity of the dialogue and emotional cues according to participants' age and experience. For younger groups, focus on simple actions such as choosing partners, sharing materials and inviting someone to join. For older groups, explore more subtle forms of exclusion, social status and unconscious bias.
Cultural / Local Adaptation: Adapt names, examples and references to local realities while preserving the central inclusion dynamic. The scenario can take place in a school, youth centre, sports club, volunteer group or international youth activity.
Accessibility Considerations: Use clear written instructions and visual support. Provide additional preparation time and facilitator assistance where needed. Participants who do not feel comfortable acting may take an observer role. Make sure that no participant is required to discuss personal experiences of exclusion.
Online Delivery Version: The scenario can be delivered through a video call. Participants may be asked to form breakout-room pairs, while Amir is repeatedly left without a partner or is moved between rooms. Participants can also create a shared digital group symbol using tools such as Miro or Canva. In larger groups, several trios can perform the scenario simultaneously, followed by a collective debrief.
