EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 03

Soft Skills and Inclusion

Explore inclusive communication, collaboration and social awareness while learning how to recognise and respond to barriers, exclusion and different group needs.

Module 3 was developed by Creative Station, Serbia, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 4 / 5

SCENARIO 4

LEFT OUT IN THE CIRCLE

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

Left Out in the Circle

Module Association

Module 3 – Soft Skills and Inclusion

Module Theme

Physical inclusion, group awareness and shared decision-making

Competences Developed

Inclusion; group awareness; communication skills; empathy; cooperative problem-solving

Target Group

Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

10–20 minutes for role-play; approximately 10 minutes for debrief

Difficulty Level

Intermediate

Format

Face-to-face or blended

Learning Objectives

Understand how physical arrangements and group dynamics can exclude certain members.
Strengthen cooperative communication and shared decision-making.
Practise empathy and recognise non-verbal cues of discomfort.
Explore how efficiency and informal leadership can reduce participation.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION

During a practical workshop, the facilitator asks the group to arrange chairs in a circle and distribute tasks for a short problem-solving activity.

While several participants immediately take control, Elena is gradually pushed towards the outer edge of the group.

Andrej and Kosta are confident and vocal.

They unintentionally dominate both the physical arrangement and the decision-making process, assuming informal leadership roles.

Mia notices the imbalance but hesitates to speak because she does not want to "disrupt the flow."

As the activity continues, Elena feels increasingly sidelined, both physically and socially.

The scenario explores how room arrangements, seating positions, body language and fast decision-making can influence inclusion.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: ELENA

Profile: An introverted and observant participant who wants to contribute but is gradually pushed to the edge of the circle.

Emotional State: Invisible, hesitant and discouraged.

Motivation: Elena wants to share an idea and be recognised as part of the group.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Elena hopes that someone will notice that she is being physically and socially excluded. She does not want to interrupt or force herself into the conversation.

ROLE 2: ANDREJ

Profile: An energetic and confident participant who quickly assumes leadership.

Emotional State: Rushed, focused and unaware.

Motivation: Andrej wants the group to organise itself quickly and move forward.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Andrej believes that efficiency justifies taking control of the physical space, task allocation and discussion.

ROLE 3: KOSTA

Profile: A participant who supports Andrej and focuses strongly on efficiency. He does not pay attention to quieter group members.

Emotional State: Impatient and unaware.

Motivation: Kosta wants the task to progress without delay.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Kosta assumes that quieter ideas are less useful or that anyone with an important contribution will speak up without being invited.

ROLE 4: MIA

Profile: A sensitive participant who notices Elena's exclusion and gradually finds the courage to intervene.

Emotional State: Concerned and conflicted.

Motivation: Mia wants the group to work fairly and respectfully.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Mia wants to speak up without creating conflict or appearing to challenge the group's progress.

D. ACTIVITY FLOW

STEP 1: PREPARATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Introduce the context, explain the role-play task and distribute the role cards. Set out chairs and allow the participants to arrange the physical space themselves.

Time: 3 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Encourage realistic behaviour and avoid exaggerated dramatisation. Do not immediately correct the seating arrangement. Allow physical exclusion to become part of the role-play.

STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY

Facilitation / Activity Step: Participants arrange the chairs, distribute tasks and begin solving the problem. Andrej and Kosta gradually dominate the process. Elena attempts to contribute but remains at the edge. Mia observes and decides when and how to intervene.

Time: 8–12 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Allow the exclusion or imbalance to emerge naturally. Pay attention to physical distance, body orientation and access to materials.

STEP 3: OBSERVATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Optional observers note communication patterns, body language, physical positioning, emotional cues and turning points.

Time: During the role-play

Notes for Facilitator: Observers should focus on: who is positioned inside or outside the circle; who handles the materials; who allocates roles; whose ideas are acknowledged; when Elena begins to disengage.

STEP 4: DEBRIEF / REFLECTION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Facilitate a discussion using the reflection questions.

Time: 10 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Explore intention versus impact. Discuss how physical space can communicate status, belonging and influence even when nobody openly excludes another person.

STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE

Facilitation / Activity Step: Connect the scenario to youth work, workshops, meetings, classrooms and project activities. Ask participants to redesign the physical setup and decision-making process to make it more inclusive.

Time: 5 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Possible strategies include: making sure everyone is physically inside the circle; rotating leadership; inviting each person to contribute; using speaking rounds; sharing access to materials; checking whether anyone has been overlooked.

E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS

How did the physical setup impact inclusion?
When did exclusion become noticeable?
What helped Elena's voice finally be heard?
How can groups intentionally build inclusive physical spaces?

F. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Chairs arranged in a circle
  • Flipchart
  • Markers
  • Printed or digital role descriptions
  • Simple problem-solving task
  • Timer

G. ADAPTATION NOTES

Adaptation for Different Groups: Adjust dialogue complexity and emotional cues according to participants' age and experience. For younger groups, focus on seating, sharing materials and taking turns. For older groups, explore informal leadership, status and power within teams.

Cultural / Local Adaptation: Adapt names, tasks and examples to local realities while preserving the central inclusion dynamic. The activity can take place in a classroom, youth centre, sports club, community meeting or training session.

Accessibility Considerations: Use clear written instructions and visual support. Provide additional preparation time and facilitator assistance where needed. Ensure that the physical setup is accessible to participants with mobility, sensory or other support needs. Do not create an arrangement that places a participant at physical risk.

Online Delivery Version: The basic scenario is designed for physical delivery, either indoors or outdoors. For online delivery, the exclusion can be represented through unequal speaking time, breakout-room placement or the order of participants shown on screen. For larger groups, form several smaller circles and run the scenario simultaneously. The activity is particularly suitable for leadership and teamwork training.