EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 04

Civic Engagement

Explore participation, community responsibility, dialogue and decision-making through scenarios connected with civic action and active citizenship.

Module 4 was developed by BIV, Türkiye, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 5 / 5

SCENARIO 5

THE RIVER PROJECT

STANDING UP FOR GREEN SPACE

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

The River Project: Standing Up for Green Space

Module Association

Module 4 – Civic Engagement

Competences Developed

Civic responsibility and participation; empathy and perspective-taking; critical and creative problem-solving; collaborative decision-making; environmental awareness

Target Group

Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

15–20 minutes

Format

Face-to-face, online or blended

Learning Objectives

Identify how young people and community members can build a common voice around a local environmental issue.
Practise empathic listening when residents, businesses and the municipality have different interests.
Design one small civic action, such as a letter, meeting, clean-up activity or public event, to influence a local decision.
Move from simply opposing a proposal to presenting a realistic alternative.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION

In a Spanish town, a small river runs near the town centre.

Young people often sit beside the river, play music and draw.

An informal youth group recently began a River Project to clean the area and paint small stones with positive messages.

The municipality is now considering cutting several trees along the riverbank to create additional parking spaces near a shopping street.

Some local shop owners support the plan.

Many young people and residents are worried that the area will become hotter, less attractive and less safe.

A meeting is organised at the local library. A youth representative, municipal engineer, shop owner, environmental volunteer and older resident meet to discuss the proposal.

They must decide whether to support the parking plan, reject it or propose an alternative. They must also identify a constructive civic action for communicating their concerns.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: ELENA

Age and Role: 20-year-old youth representative

Profile: Elena coordinates the informal River Project youth group.

Emotional State and Motivation: Elena is proud of the group's clean-up work. She feels sad and angry about the proposal to remove trees.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Elena wants to protect the green area and demonstrate that young people are responsible citizens rather than lazy young people spending time by the river.

ROLE 2: CARLOS

Age and Role: 45-year-old municipal engineer

Profile: Carlos works for the municipality and helped design the parking plan.

Emotional State and Motivation: Carlos focuses on technical solutions and traffic problems. He feels misunderstood when people reject plans without proposing alternatives.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Carlos wants the project to move forward. He is open to small changes if an alternative is realistic and does not create major additional costs.

ROLE 3: MARTA

Age and Role: 39-year-old shop owner

Profile: Marta owns a small clothing shop near the river.

Emotional State and Motivation: Marta is worried about low sales. She hopes additional parking will attract more customers.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Marta wants others to understand that local shops are part of community life and are not enemies of green spaces.

ROLE 4: LUCÍA

Age and Role: 27-year-old environmental volunteer

Profile: Lucía is a member of a local environmental association.

Emotional State and Motivation: Lucía is highly protective of trees and biodiversity. She becomes emotional when people discuss cutting trees.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Lucía wants a clear public commitment to protect the riverbank. She also sees the situation as an opportunity to raise environmental awareness.

ROLE 5: JOSÉ

Age and Role: 68-year-old older resident

Profile: José has lived in the neighbourhood for forty years and walks beside the river every morning.

Emotional State and Motivation: José feels nostalgic and worries that green areas are disappearing. He also understands that parking is sometimes difficult.

Goal / Hidden Intention: José wants peace and dialogue. He hopes younger and older residents can work together to protect at least part of the green area.

D. SUGGESTED ROLE-PLAY SCRIPT

Setting: The library meeting room is quiet. A large photograph of the river hangs on the wall. A printed map of the riverbank is placed on the table, with red lines showing the planned parking spaces. Elena has a notebook. Lucía has a folder containing photographs of birds and trees. Marta checks her phone. José leans on his walking stick. Carlos organises his papers.

Elena: "Thank you all for coming. I know we see the river in different ways, but we all live in the same town. Perhaps we can begin with a short round. What does the river mean to you, and what do you think about the parking plan?"

José: "For me, the river is memory. I used to bring my children here. Now I walk here every morning. The trees provide shade. I do not like the idea of removing them, but I also know parking is difficult on Saturdays."

Marta: "Exactly. On Saturdays, people drive around looking for spaces and then go to the large shopping centre outside town. My shop is often empty. If they could park nearby, perhaps they would stay here. I do not want to destroy nature, but I must pay my rent."

Lucía, opening her folder: "These trees are not simply decoration. Birds nest here, and the shade keeps the river cool. If we remove them, we lose more than greenery. We lose protection against heat and flooding."

Carlos: "I hear you, but we also have data. Traffic studies indicate that approximately twenty new parking spaces are needed in this area. The proposal removes only a limited number of trees. We will plant replacement trees in another part of town."

Elena, calmly: "Let me summarise.

  • José values the river because of daily life and memories.
  • Marta is worried that poor access will harm her business.
  • Lucía is concerned about biodiversity and climate.
  • Carlos needs to address traffic problems and follow the municipal plan.

For our youth group, the river is where we meet, clean, draw and feel part of the town. We do not want to fight. We want a solution that keeps the river alive."

Marta, slightly softer: "I have seen your clean-up activities. The area has improved since you began. I respect that. But where should people park?"

Lucía: "Perhaps the question is not whether we choose parking or trees, but where and how parking is created. Are there empty areas on the other side of the street? Could angle parking be used rather than removing the whole line of trees?"

Carlos, leaning over the map: "We considered that option, but it is more expensive. However, if there were strong community support, perhaps the council would listen."

Elena: "What would strong support mean?"

Carlos: "A clear and realistic counter-proposal with signatures and a simple sketch. Not only saying no, but saying yes to an alternative."

D. SUGGESTED ROLE-PLAY SCRIPT (continued)

José: "Could we propose keeping the trees closest to the river and creating fewer parking spaces, perhaps ten instead of twenty, further from the water?"

Marta: "Ten spaces are better than none. If we also communicate that shops remain open and are easy to reach on foot, it might work."

Lucía: "We could organise a River Day with the youth group and the environmental association. We invite people to come by bicycle or bus, show them the birds, organise a clean-up and collect signatures for the alternative plan."

Elena, visibly excited: "Yes. Young people could prepare posters and short videos explaining why the trees matter. We could share them on social media and collect both online and paper signatures supporting José's idea: fewer parking spaces and no tree removal beside the water."

Carlos, thinking: "If you bring me a simple sketch and at least one hundred signatures, I can attach them to my report. I cannot promise the council will agree, but it will be difficult to ignore."

Marta: "I can keep the petition in my shop. People visit anyway. It is worth the effort if we can protect the river and still support local businesses."

José: "I will speak to my walking group. We may be older, but we can still sign and speak."

Elena: "Thank you. Our plan is:

  • Prepare an alternative map with fewer parking spaces located further from the riverbank.
  • Collect signatures in shops and during a river clean-up.
  • Organise a River Day to raise awareness.
  • Ask Carlos to present the proposal and signatures to the council.

Does this sound like a step everyone can accept?

Everyone nods, although some are more convinced than others.

Elena, smiling: "Then our River Project has become a real civic action, not only a clean-up."

E. INSTRUCTIONS FOR PARTICIPANTS

Read Your Role Card

Time: 3 minutes

Think about:

  • What do I want?
  • What am I worried about?
  • What opening sentence will I use?

Opening Round

Time: 3 minutes

Each role explains:

  • what the river means to them;
  • how they view the parking plan.

Discussion and Decision

Time: 7 minutes

Discuss whether to support the current plan, reject it, or propose an alternative. Try to agree on one small civic action, such as:

  • a petition;
  • a public meeting;
  • a River Day;
  • an alternative map;
  • a clean-up event;
  • a written proposal.

Summary

Time: 2 minutes

Write a River Proposal containing:

  • what the group wants to protect;
  • what change the group proposes;
  • what action the group will take to be heard.

F. FACILITATOR INSTRUCTIONS

Create groups of four or five participants and assign the roles.

Remind participants that the goal is to practise civic dialogue and joint problem-solving rather than to develop a perfect urban-planning solution.

Encourage participants to:

  • summarise one another's needs;
  • search for "yes, if" options instead of only saying no;
  • propose realistic and specific actions;
  • distinguish between positions and underlying interests.

During the debrief, connect the activity to Module 4 tools including:

  • mapping a local issue;
  • stakeholder analysis;
  • mini civic projects;
  • combining online and offline participation.

G. REFLECTION QUESTIONS

How did your opinion change (or not) during the discussion?
Which arguments helped the group move from conflict to a shared proposal?
What made your civic action realistic or unrealistic?
Can you think of a real place in your town that needs a similar discussion?
What is one small civic step you could start this month with your group?

H. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Printed or digital role cards
  • Simple river map on A3 paper or flipchart
  • Markers and pens
  • Paper for the River Proposal
  • Optional petition template
  • Timer

I. ADAPTATION NOTES

Country Adaptation

Change the river, town and stakeholders according to the local context while preserving the environmental conflict and civic participation elements.

Alternative Environmental Issue

Replace the parking proposal with another pressure on green space, such as:

  • a new road;
  • a commercial terrace;
  • a fence;
  • a building project;
  • removal of a playground;
  • development of a public square.

Younger Groups

Provide two pre-drawn alternative maps. Participants choose one option and explain why they support it rather than creating a new map from the beginning.

Online Delivery Version

Use a digital map or shared whiteboard. Participants can add proposed parking spaces, protected areas and alternative routes digitally. The final proposal can be written in a shared document.

Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are, however, those of the author or authors only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Education and Culture Executive Agency (EACEA). Neither the European Union nor EACEA can be held responsible for them.