EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 04

Civic Engagement

Explore participation, community responsibility, dialogue and decision-making through scenarios connected with civic action and active citizenship.

Module 4 was developed by BIV, Türkiye, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 2 / 5

SCENARIO 2

THE PETITION

CLICKING FOR CHANGE OR CAUSING HARM?

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

The Petition: Clicking for Change or Causing Harm?

Module Association

Module 4 – Civic Engagement

Competences Developed

Civic responsibility and participation; digital responsibility and safety; critical thinking; teamwork and shared decision-making; empathy and inclusive communication

Target Group

Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

15–20 minutes

Format

Face-to-face, online or blended

Learning Objectives

Identify at least two risks and two benefits of using online petitions and social media in civic campaigns.
Practise making a group decision about how to respond to injustice using both online and offline tools.
Reflect on respectful and responsible digital communication when people disagree.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION

In a small European city, a multicultural youth group uses a community centre for weekly meetings.

The group recently proposed a street-art mural on a public wall to celebrate diversity and inclusion.

Initially, the municipality appeared positive, but the local council is now postponing the decision after receiving complaints from several neighbours.

A short article about the mural appears in a local online newspaper. Comments below the article include statements such as:

  • "We do not need foreign flags on our walls."
  • "These young people should study instead of painting propaganda."

Screenshots of the comments are shared in the youth group's WhatsApp chat.

Some participants feel hurt and angry and want to react immediately.

A smaller group meets at the youth centre to decide whether they should launch an online petition and social media campaign.

They must also consider how to defend the project without spreading hate, exposing personal data or damaging their relationship with the municipality.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: ELIF

Age and Role: 19-year-old student

Profile: Elif studies graphic design and helped create the mural concept. She is very active on Instagram and TikTok.

Emotional State and Motivation: Elif feels personally attacked by the online comments. She is angry, hurt and impatient.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Elif wants to launch a strong online petition and hashtag campaign that shows the community that the youth group belongs in the city. She is willing to create public tension if necessary.

ROLE 2: MARKO

Age and Role: 20-year-old exchange student

Profile: Marko is participating in an Erasmus exchange and volunteers at the youth centre. He has previous activism experience.

Emotional State and Motivation: Marko believes racism is frequently ignored. He does not trust public institutions.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Marko wants to publicly call out the hateful comments by publishing screenshots and the commenters' names. He believes careful or diplomatic language is ineffective.

ROLE 3: ANNA

Role: Youth worker

Profile: Anna works at the youth centre and is the main contact with the municipality.

Emotional State and Motivation: Anna understands the young people's frustration but is concerned about online hate, privacy, personal safety and the relationship with the municipality.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Anna wants a balanced strategy that keeps the mural project alive, protects the young people and preserves long-term relationships with local authorities.

ROLE 4: GIULIA

Age and Role: 21-year-old student representative

Profile: Giulia represents the youth group at school and at the centre. She is diplomatic and careful.

Emotional State and Motivation: Giulia is nervous about public conflict. She fears the school director will react negatively if the campaign becomes too political.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Giulia wants a safer strategy, such as an open letter or private meeting, but does not want her friends to think she is weak or unwilling to act.

ROLE 5: JAVIER

Age and Role: 22-year-old social media volunteer

Profile: Javier supports non-governmental organisations with social media campaigns and knows basic digital safety rules.

Emotional State and Motivation: Javier is excited about the campaign opportunity but is careful about tone, privacy and the group's long-term reputation.

Goal / Hidden Intention: Javier wants a strategic campaign with a clear message, group consent and no direct personal attacks.

D. SUGGESTED ROLE-PLAY SCRIPT

Setting: The youth centre meeting room is filled with posters and coloured markers. Elif scrolls through her phone, visibly angry. Marko walks near the window. Giulia sits with a notebook on her lap. Javier types on his laptop. Anna stands beside a flipchart.

Anna: "Thank you for coming. I know the online comments were harsh. Let us take a breath and decide together what to do next."

Elif, shaking her head: "A breath will not change anything, Anna. Look at this one: 'Foreign flags on our walls? No, thanks.' They speak about us as if we are a disease."

Marko: "This is exactly what I expected. They smile during meetings and then complain online. We should respond immediately. Post the screenshots and show their names. Let everyone see who is spreading hate."

Giulia, worried: "If we do that, the situation could become very ugly. The school director already told me to be careful with politics. If this becomes a major conflict, they may cancel everything."

Javier: "I understand both sides. Online pressure can help, but it can also turn against us. Once we post something, we cannot take it back. The comments could go viral in a harmful way."

Elif: "So what? Are we supposed to remain silent? They insult us and our idea. If we do nothing, the council will think we do not care."

Anna, calmly: "Elif, I hear that you feel invisible and disrespected. Marko, you are tired of false promises. At the same time, Giulia is afraid of losing school support, and Javier is considering the long-term effects. Can we agree that our shared goal is to defend the mural project and keep young people safe?"

The group nods slowly.

Anna: "Let us put some options on the table. Marko, what would you do first if it were only your decision?"

Marko: "Easy. We launch an online petition tonight. The title is: 'Stop racism. Let us paint our mural.' We share it everywhere, tag the mayor and the newspaper and post the hateful comments with names."

Giulia: "That sounds strong. Perhaps too strong. If we attack the council or individuals, they may become defensive. They could describe us as extremists."

Elif: "But we are angry. Why pretend that we are not?"

Javier: "We can show anger without attacking individuals or breaking rules. What if we focus on a positive message? For example: 'Young people for a colourful and inclusive city.' We can explain that we received harmful comments, but hide names and profile pictures."

Marko, crossing his arms: "Hiding their names protects them, not us."

D. SUGGESTED ROLE-PLAY SCRIPT (continued)

Anna: "There is also the issue of data protection and personal safety. Publishing names and photographs without consent could create legal problems and more online abuse. I do not want any of you to become targets."

Elif, taking a deep breath: "What about this? We launch a petition with a positive title. We include one screenshot as an example, but blur the name. We explain why the comment is harmful and describe the kind of city we want instead."

Giulia: "We could combine it with an offline action. We can request a meeting with the council and bring the petition signatures as evidence of support rather than as an attack."

Javier: "Yes. I can help write the text so it is strong but respectful. We can include a short story explaining why the mural matters: different languages, flags and faces showing that we all belong here."

Marko, reluctantly: "Fine. But we must clearly say that hate is unacceptable. I do not want a weak message."

Anna, smiling slightly: "We can be clear without insulting anyone. For example: 'We reject hateful comments and discrimination, and we invite the council to stand with us.' That is firm and civic."

Elif: "I like that. Could we also add a hashtag? Perhaps #OurCityOurWall in several languages?"

Javier: "Good idea. That demonstrates that this is a wider European issue. I can prepare simple Instagram visuals. We will not show anyone's face or name, only our mural designs and short quotes from the group."

Giulia: "I will speak to the school director before we publish. If we demonstrate that we are acting responsibly and transparently, the school may support us rather than stop us."

Anna: "Let us summarise.

  • We create a positive and clear petition with our main message and one blurred screenshot as an example.
  • We prepare respectful social media posts in several languages.
  • We request a meeting with the council and present the signatures and our proposal.

Is this our final decision?

Everyone looks at each other.

Marko, nodding slowly: "Yes. I still want to shout, but this feels like a real plan."

Elif: "Me too. At least we are doing something together."

Javier: "I will begin drafting the petition tonight and share it in the group chat."

Giulia: "I will email the school director and request a short meeting tomorrow."

Anna: "I will inform my municipal contact that the young people are preparing a constructive response. I am proud of you. This is civic engagement in action."

E. INSTRUCTIONS FOR PARTICIPANTS

Read Your Role Card

Time: 3 minutes

Think about:

  • What do I want?
  • What am I afraid of?
  • What will my opening statement be?

Opening Round

Time: 3 minutes

Each role shares:

  • how they feel about the online comments;
  • what action they want the group to take.

Discussion and Decision

Time: 7 minutes

Participants react in role, disagree and propose options. Choose one joint strategy. Consider:

  • Will you launch a petition?
  • What tone and message will you use?
  • Will you combine online and offline actions?
  • How will you protect personal data and participant safety?

Summary

Time: 2 minutes

Agree on a short campaign plan containing:

  • the main message;
  • one digital action;
  • one offline action;
  • individual responsibilities.

F. FACILITATOR INSTRUCTIONS

Create groups of four or five participants and assign the roles.

Remind participants that the goal is to explore responsible civic use of digital tools, not to find a perfect answer.

Encourage everyone to remain in role while avoiding personal attacks.

If the discussion becomes limited to extreme choices such as doing nothing or launching a full public attack, pause and ask:

  • What is your shared goal?
  • Which option protects the group while still communicating a strong message?

During the debrief, connect the discussion to Module 4 themes including:

  • digital participation;
  • digital safety;
  • civic advocacy;
  • combining online and offline action.

G. REFLECTION QUESTIONS

How did you feel when deciding how to answer the online comments?
Which arguments for a "strong" campaign convinced you?
Which arguments for a "careful" campaign convinced you?
What risks do you see in using petitions and social media for civic action?
What opportunities do you see?
How can young people protect themselves from online hate while still speaking up?
How could you use a similar campaign in your own community or youth group?

H. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Printed or digital role cards
  • Flipchart or A3 paper
  • Markers and pens
  • Optional laptop or phone
  • Example petition layout
  • Campaign planning sheet

I. ADAPTATION NOTES

Country Adaptation

Change the city, comment language, mural theme or local institutions to fit the national context.

Younger Groups

Provide two or three pre-written campaign options that participants can choose and adapt.

Online Delivery Version

Use breakout rooms and share roles digitally. Groups can write their campaign plan on a shared board or collaborative document.