SCENARIO 3 – TOO MANY QUESTIONS
A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW
Scenario Title | Too Many Questions |
Module Association | Module 2 – Role-Playing and Emotional Communication |
Module Theme | Active listening, non-verbal communication, empathetic responses and repairing misunderstandings |
Competences Developed | Active listening; empathy; emotional regulation; constructive communication; conflict resolution; perspective-taking |
Target Group | Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training |
Duration | 10–20 minutes for role-play; 15–20 minutes for debrief |
Difficulty Level | Intermediate |
Format | Face-to-face, online or blended |
Learning Objectives

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION – Scenario 3
Three co-workers are having a conversation.
Bella and Susan are speaking with Daniel, who has recently joined their workplace.
Bella is outgoing, talkative and known for being chatty.
Susan is more reserved but still friendly and takes a listening role in the conversation.
Bella asks Daniel many questions.
As the conversation continues, Daniel's answers become shorter and more abrupt.
Bella interprets Daniel's behaviour as rude and begins lecturing him about the importance of making a good first impression.
Susan notices Daniel's body language changing when Bella continues asking personal questions about his family.
Susan must decide whether to intervene and how to help both co-workers communicate.
The scenario explores how missed emotional signals, personal boundaries and defensive communication can damage relationships, and how active listening and empathy can repair them.
C. ROLES
ROLE 1: BELLA
Profile of the Character
An enthusiastic and outgoing person who enjoys talking and getting to know the people around her. She prides herself on being friendly.
Emotional State
Confused and frustrated by Daniel's apparently rude responses to what she considers friendly conversation.
Motivation
Bella wants to get to know Daniel and make it clear that she thinks his responses are unfriendly.
Goal / Hidden Intention
Bella previously worked in an unfriendly workplace. When she began working in her current workplace, she promised herself that she would help create a friendly atmosphere. She perceives Daniel's reserved behaviour as a threat to that atmosphere and wants him to understand that he cannot behave in a way she considers rude.
ROLE 2: DANIEL
Profile of the Character
A highly private person who goes to work primarily to complete his responsibilities rather than to make friends. Daniel is not intentionally unfriendly, but prefers to keep workplace conversations at a surface level.
Emotional State
Frustrated by Bella and her increasingly personal questions. He feels uncomfortable discussing subjects he does not want to share and does not appreciate being lectured about behaviour he already understands.
Motivation
Daniel initially wanted to speak with his new co-workers, but now feels that they will not stop asking intrusive questions. He wants to return to his work.
Goal / Hidden Intention
Daniel has a complicated relationship with his family. It is not something he discusses at work. He is annoyed with Bella and feels offended by her personal questions.
ROLE 3: SUSAN
Profile of the Character
An observant and emotionally intelligent person. Susan's way of being friendly is to ensure that everyone feels comfortable.
Emotional State
Concerned as she sees the conversation deteriorating into a lecture. Susan wants both people to understand what went wrong and hopes to restore a comfortable atmosphere.
Motivation
Susan works better when she knows that her co-workers feel comfortable. Team morale is important to her and contributes to a better working environment.
Goal / Hidden Intention
Susan does not want the workplace to become somewhere she dreads because of an unpleasant atmosphere. Helping other people feel welcome and comfortable also makes her feel more at ease.
D. ACTIVITY FLOW – Scenario 3
STEP 1: PREPARATION
Facilitation / Activity Step
Explain the scenario and distribute the role cards.
Give participants a few minutes to read their roles and think about their character's emotional state, posture and tone of voice.
Remind participants that the goal is to explore communication dynamics, not to "win" the argument.
Time: 5 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Emphasise that the scenario focuses on the breakdown and repair of communication.
Daniel should not be portrayed simply as a victim, but as someone who has been offended and placed in an uncomfortable position.
Bella should not be portrayed as a bully, but as someone trying to solve what she believes is a problem.
Susan should not be portrayed as a superhero, but as a more neutral person who notices non-verbal cues.
STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY
Facilitation / Activity Step
Participants act out a conversation beginning with introductions because Daniel is new.
The conversation should develop naturally as Bella's questions become increasingly personal and move towards Daniel's family.
Daniel's body language and tone begin to change.
Bella also becomes more defensive because she interprets Daniel's responses as rude.
Susan must decide when and how to intervene to address the misunderstanding.
Time: 10–15 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Encourage participants to allow the tension to develop naturally.
The turning point is important. This is the moment when Bella or Daniel must change their communication approach.
Allow the scene to have an open ending.
STEP 3: OBSERVATION
Facilitation / Activity Step
Optional observers note non-verbal cues, including body language, eye contact and tone of voice.
They should also note moments of escalation, such as accusations, lectures or withdrawal, and the moment when communication begins to shift.
Time: During the role-play
Notes for Facilitator
Observers can use a simple sheet with three questions:
- "What was said?"
- "What did the body language communicate?"
- "What emotion did it show?"
STEP 4: DEBRIEF / REFLECTION – Scenario 3
Facilitation / Activity Step
Facilitate a group discussion using the reflection questions.
Focus on the difference between friendliness and intrusion, the importance of personal boundaries, the impact of non-verbal communication and how empathy can change the outcome of a difficult conversation.
Time: 15–20 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Guide the discussion from "What happened?" towards "What could have been done differently?"
Pay particular attention to Susan's role as an observer and intervener.
STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE
Facilitation / Activity Step
Ask participants to create a short "Respectful Communication Checklist".
This could include principles such as:
- “Notice when someone gives short answers or changes their body language.”
- “Do not pressure people to share personal information.”
- “Ask whether someone is comfortable discussing a topic.”
- “Respect a person's right not to answer.”
Time: 5–10 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Encourage participants to consider how they can apply these insights in youth organisations, volunteering, school, training and workplace settings.
E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS
F. MATERIALS NEEDED
- Printed or digital role cards
- A table and chairs arranged in a small triangle or semicircle
- Optional observer sheet for tracking non-verbal cues
- Pens and paper for note-taking
- Timer
G. ADAPTATION NOTES – Scenario 3
Adaptation for Different Groups
For younger participants aged 15–16, place the scenario in a school, youth club or volunteering environment rather than a formal workplace.
The questions could concern friendships, family expectations or future plans.
For older participants aged 19–21, add more complex workplace dynamics, such as pressure to fit into a new team or fear of appearing unfriendly.
Cultural / Local Adaptation
Adapt the names, setting and personal questions to the local context.
The situation could take place in:
- a part-time workplace;
- a youth organisation;
- a sports team;
- a school project;
- a volunteering initiative.
Consider cultural differences in expectations around privacy, friendliness and personal conversation.
Accessibility Considerations
Provide clear and concise role cards with the key emotional states highlighted.
Allow participants to observe instead of acting if they do not feel comfortable taking part.
Participants who find it difficult to express emotions verbally can focus on physical posture, facial expression and other non-verbal cues.
Introduce a clear "pause" signal, such as raising a hand, which any participant can use if the role-play becomes too intense.
Online Delivery Version
This scenario can be delivered through a video call.
The limited physical presence can become part of the learning activity.
Ask participants: "How do we recognise discomfort when we can only see someone's face on a screen?"
The turning point could happen when Bella notices Daniel's facial expression changing or when Susan sends Daniel or Bella a private message before speaking to the group.
The debrief can take place in the main meeting room or through a collaborative digital board where participants can contribute anonymous written reflections.
The Respectful Communication Checklist can be created in a shared online document.
