EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 02

Role-Playing and Emotional Communication

Develop active listening, emotional communication and awareness of how verbal and non-verbal behaviour influences relationships and group interactions.

Module 2 was developed by AIS, Austria, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 5 / 5

SCENARIO 5 – JUST A JOKE

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

Just a Joke

Module Association

Module 2 – Role-Playing and Emotional Communication

Module Theme

Active listening, non-verbal communication, empathetic responses and repairing misunderstandings

Competences Developed

Active listening; empathy; emotional regulation; constructive communication; conflict resolution; perspective-taking

Target Group

Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

10–20 minutes for role-play; 15–20 minutes for debrief

Difficulty Level

Intermediate

Format

Face-to-face, online or blended

Learning Objectives

Identify and interpret non-verbal cues, including body language, tone and silence, that signal emotional discomfort.
Practise active listening and empathetic questioning when someone feels hurt by humour or teasing.
Explore how dismissive responses can escalate conflict and how empathetic communication can repair it.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION – Scenario 5

Three members of a youth organisation are preparing for an event.

Liam makes a joke about a mistake Priya made during a previous activity.

Liam believes the comment is harmless and expects everyone to laugh.

Priya smiles at first but gradually becomes quieter and less engaged as the conversation continues.

Sam notices the change in Priya's behaviour while Liam remains unaware that anything is wrong.

When Liam continues making similar jokes, the tension grows.

Sam must decide how to address the situation and help repair the communication.

The scenario explores the impact of humour, emotional awareness and empathetic communication.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: LIAM

Profile of the Character

A friendly and outgoing person who enjoys making people laugh.

Emotional State

Initially cheerful and relaxed, but later confused and defensive when others react negatively.

Motivation

Liam wants to keep the atmosphere light and entertaining.

Goal / Hidden Intention

Liam believes that teasing is a sign of friendship and does not realise that his repeated jokes are becoming hurtful.

ROLE 2: PRIYA

Profile of the Character

A capable and hardworking person who cares about doing well.

Emotional State

Embarrassed, hurt and increasingly withdrawn.

Motivation

Priya wants to avoid conflict and maintain a positive group atmosphere.

Goal / Hidden Intention

Priya feels singled out but is uncomfortable confronting Liam directly. She hopes that he will notice her discomfort and stop without her having to challenge him publicly.

ROLE 3: SAM

Profile of the Character

An observant group member who values respectful communication.

Emotional State

Concerned for Priya and increasingly uncomfortable with the direction of the conversation.

Motivation

Sam wants to maintain a positive and inclusive group environment.

Goal / Hidden Intention

Sam wants Liam to understand the impact of his words without making either Liam or Priya feel attacked or humiliated.

D. ACTIVITY FLOW – Scenario 5

STEP 1: PREPARATION

Facilitation / Activity Step

Explain the scenario and distribute the role cards.

Give participants a few minutes to read their roles and think about their character's emotional state, posture and tone of voice.

Remind participants that the goal is to explore communication dynamics, not to "win" the argument.

Time: 5 minutes

Notes for Facilitator

Emphasise that the scenario focuses on the breakdown and repair of communication.

Liam should not be portrayed as intentionally cruel. He genuinely believes he is being funny and does not initially recognise the impact of his words.

Priya should not be portrayed as oversensitive. She feels publicly embarrassed and is unsure how to respond.

Sam should not be portrayed as a superhero, but as an observer who notices non-verbal cues and must decide how to intervene.

STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY

Facilitation / Activity Step

Participants act out a planning conversation for an upcoming youth event.

Liam refers to a mistake Priya made during a previous activity and turns it into a joke.

Priya initially smiles politely but becomes quieter as Liam repeats or develops the joke.

Her posture, facial expression and level of participation begin to change.

Sam observes the interaction and decides when and how to intervene.

Time: 10–15 minutes

Notes for Facilitator

Encourage participants to allow the tension to develop naturally.

The turning point is important. This is the moment when Liam must recognise Priya's discomfort, Priya must express how she feels, or Sam must intervene.

Allow the scene to have an open ending.

STEP 3: OBSERVATION

Facilitation / Activity Step

Optional observers note non-verbal cues, including body language, eye contact, forced laughter, silence and tone of voice.

They should also note moments when the jokes become uncomfortable and when communication begins to shift.

Time: During the role-play

Notes for Facilitator

Observers can use a simple sheet with three questions:

  • What was said?
  • What did the body language communicate?
  • What emotion did it show?

STEP 4: DEBRIEF / REFLECTION

Facilitation / Activity Step

Facilitate a group discussion using the reflection questions.

Focus on the difference between intention and impact, the role of non-verbal communication and how empathy can change the outcome of the interaction.

Time: 15–20 minutes

Notes for Facilitator

Guide the discussion from "What happened?" towards "What could have been done differently?"

Pay particular attention to Sam's role as an observer and intervener.

Discuss how Liam could acknowledge the impact of the joke without becoming defensive and how Priya could communicate a boundary safely.

STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE

Facilitation / Activity Step

Ask participants to create a short "Respectful Humour Checklist".

This could include principles such as:

  • Notice whether everyone is genuinely laughing.
  • Do not repeatedly joke about one person's mistake.
  • Stop when someone looks uncomfortable.
  • Do not use 'It was just a joke' to dismiss someone's feelings.
  • Apologise for the impact, even when harm was not intended.

Time: 5–10 minutes

Notes for Facilitator

Encourage participants to consider how these principles apply in youth groups, schools, teams, online communication and friendships.

E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS – Scenario 5

What non-verbal cues suggested that Priya was uncomfortable?
Why did Liam not realise that his jokes were causing harm?
How can humour create misunderstandings?
What did Sam do to address the situation?
What could Priya have done to express her feelings earlier?
How can people balance humour with respect for others?
What is the difference between Liam's intention and the impact of his words?
What makes a genuine apology effective in this situation?

F. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Printed or digital role cards
  • A table and chairs arranged in a small triangle or semicircle
  • Optional observer sheet for tracking non-verbal cues
  • Pens and paper for note-taking
  • Timer

G. ADAPTATION NOTES – Scenario 5

Adaptation for Different Groups

For younger participants aged 15–16, use a familiar situation involving teasing during a school activity, sports practice or youth club meeting.

For older participants aged 19–21, add more complex group dynamics, such as repeated public teasing, power differences or jokes shared through social media.

Cultural / Local Adaptation

Adapt the names, event and type of joke to the local context.

The situation could take place during:

  • a school event;
  • a sports activity;
  • a youth project;
  • a volunteering initiative;
  • an online group conversation.

Avoid using jokes that directly target the real identities, backgrounds, appearances or personal experiences of participants.

Accessibility Considerations

Provide clear and concise role cards with the key emotional states highlighted.

Allow participants to observe instead of acting if they do not feel comfortable taking part.

Participants who find it difficult to express emotions verbally can focus on physical posture, facial expression and other non-verbal cues.

Introduce a clear "pause" signal, such as raising a hand, which any participant can use if the role-play becomes too intense.

Online Delivery Version

This scenario can be delivered through a video call or group chat.

Liam may post a joke, meme or comment about Priya's previous mistake.

Priya may initially respond with an emoji but later stop participating, turn off her camera or stop replying.

Sam may send Priya a private supportive message before addressing the issue in the group.

The debrief can take place in the main meeting room or through a collaborative digital board where participants can contribute anonymous written reflections.

The Respectful Humour Checklist can be created in a shared online document.

DISCLAIMER

Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are, however, those of the author or authors only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Education and Culture Executive Agency (EACEA). Neither the European Union nor EACEA can be held responsible for them.