SCENARIO 2 – WHAT GOES UNHEARD
A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW
Scenario Title | What Goes Unheard |
Module Association | Module 2 – Role-Playing and Emotional Communication |
Module Theme | Active listening, non-verbal communication, empathetic responses and repairing misunderstandings |
Competences Developed | Active listening; empathy; emotional regulation; constructive communication; conflict resolution; perspective-taking |
Target Group | Young people aged 15–21; youth workers and facilitators in training |
Duration | 10–20 minutes for role-play; 15–20 minutes for debrief |
Difficulty Level | Intermediate |
Format | Face-to-face, online or blended |
Learning Objectives

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION – Scenario 2
Three friends, Anna, Mark and Elena, want to start a running club in their local area.
Anna came up with the idea and has been enthusiastically leading the project. However, she has recently been arriving late to their meetings.
Mark is focused on how the running club could reflect well on his CV. He becomes annoyed with Anna and believes that she is not committed enough.
Mark begins making comments about Anna being late.
Anna and Mark start talking over each other, and their growing frustration develops into a serious argument.
Elena is calm and considerate and joined the project to support her friends.
She must decide how to communicate effectively and bridge the gap forming between Anna and Mark.
The scenario explores how a lack of active listening, missed emotional signals, unspoken personal stress and defensive communication can damage relationships, and how empathy can help repair them.
C. ROLES
ROLE 1: ANNA
Profile of the Character
An enthusiastic person who has always been vocal about her love of running. She is usually cheerful and motivated to achieve her goals.
Emotional State
Sad, resigned and increasingly frustrated. She experiences Mark's comments as hurtful and unnecessarily blaming.
Motivation
Anna wants to start a running club with her friends and create a space where they can enjoy something she loves.
Goal / Hidden Intention
Anna has recently received a medical diagnosis which means she can no longer run. She is grieving the loss of an activity that was important to her. She has been late to meetings because of medical appointments but has not told her friends because she was hoping for a better outcome.
ROLE 2: MARK
Profile of the Character
A highly goal-driven and independent person who wants to accomplish as much as possible for his future.
Emotional State
Frustrated and outspoken. Mark believes that Anna is not trying hard enough to achieve a goal they agreed on as a group. He is not listening carefully to what she is saying.
Motivation
Mark is nervous about his future and wants to achieve goals that may improve his chances of entering university.
Goal / Hidden Intention
Mark wants the club to begin and wants Anna to take the project more seriously. He feels that he is the only person in the group who cares whether they actually start the club.
ROLE 3: ELENA
Profile of the Character
An observant and emotionally intelligent group member who values team cohesion. She is usually more comfortable listening and tends not to take leadership roles.
Emotional State
Stressed by the argument between Anna and Mark. She understands parts of both perspectives, feels sad for Anna and has empathy for Mark. She is frustrated that they do not appear to hear each other.
Motivation
Elena wants her friends to continue working together and still hopes that the running club can happen.
Goal / Hidden Intention
Elena wanted a space where she could spend time with her friends and supported the running club because it was important to them. She is sensitive to arguments and does not want to take sides. She wants to help Anna and Mark understand each other and reach a shared understanding.
D. ACTIVITY FLOW – Scenario 2
STEP 1: PREPARATION
Facilitation / Activity Step
Explain the scenario and distribute the role cards.
Give participants a few minutes to read their roles and think about their character's emotional state, posture and tone of voice.
Remind participants that the goal is to explore the communication dynamics, not to "win" the argument.
Time: 5 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Emphasise that the scenario focuses on the breakdown and repair of communication.
Anna should not be portrayed simply as a victim, but as someone grieving the loss of something that gave her purpose and trying to understand her new situation.
Mark should not be portrayed as a bully, but as someone who is stressed and not listening.
Elena should not be portrayed as a superhero, but as someone who cares enough about her friends to overcome her discomfort with arguments and try to bridge the gap between them.
STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY
Facilitation / Activity Step
Participants act out a planning session.
The scene begins with Mark commenting on Anna's lack of commitment.
Anna arrives after the conversation has begun.
The tension develops as Mark talks about work ethic and Anna tries to explain that her situation is not a question of commitment or effort.
Elena listens to the escalating argument and decides when and how to intervene.
Time: 10–15 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Encourage participants to allow the tension to develop naturally.
The turning point is important. This is the moment when Anna or Mark must change their communication approach.
Allow the scene to have an open ending.
STEP 3: OBSERVATION
Facilitation / Activity Step
Optional observers note non-verbal cues, including body language, eye contact and tone of voice.
They should also note moments of escalation, such as sarcasm or blame, and the moment when communication begins to shift.
Time: During the role-play
Notes for Facilitator
Observers can use a simple sheet with three questions:
- "What was said?"
- "What did the body language communicate?"
- "What emotion did it show?"
STEP 4: DEBRIEF / REFLECTION – Scenario 2
Facilitation / Activity Step
Facilitate a group discussion using the reflection questions.
Focus on the difference between hearing and listening, the impact of non-verbal communication and how empathy can change the outcome of a difficult conversation.
Time: 15–20 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Guide the discussion from "What happened?" towards "What could have been done differently?"
Pay particular attention to Elena's role as an observer and intervener.
STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE
Facilitation / Activity Step
Ask participants to create a short "Communication Checklist" for youth projects.
This could include principles such as:
- "Check in with teammates before making assumptions."
- "Use 'I' statements."
- "Ask open-ended questions to understand."
Time: 5–10 minutes
Notes for Facilitator
Encourage participants to consider how they can apply these insights in their own group work, youth activities and personal lives.
E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS
F. MATERIALS NEEDED
- Printed or digital role cards
- A table and chairs arranged in a small triangle or semicircle
- Optional observer sheet for tracking non-verbal cues
- Pens and paper for note-taking
- Timer

G. ADAPTATION NOTES – Scenario 2
Adaptation for Different Groups
For younger participants aged 15–16, simplify the situation.
Anna could be dealing with an injury, such as a concussion, that affects her ability to participate in sport.
For older participants aged 19–21, make the scenario more complex by introducing a higher-stakes initiative, such as starting a social enterprise or another project that affects people beyond the three characters.
Cultural / Local Adaptation
Adapt the names, the type of club and the stressors to the local context.
The project could involve:
- a school club;
- a sports team;
- a cultural festival;
- a community event;
- a volunteering initiative.
The personal stressor can reflect locally relevant challenges, such as family expectations, part-time work, university application anxiety or common injuries.
Accessibility Considerations
Provide clear and concise role cards with the key emotional states highlighted.
Allow participants to observe instead of acting if they do not feel comfortable taking part.
Participants who find it difficult to express emotions verbally can focus on physical posture, facial expression and other non-verbal cues.
Introduce a clear "pause" signal, such as raising a hand, which any participant can use if the role-play becomes too intense.
Online Delivery Version
This scenario can be delivered through a video call.
The limited physical presence can become part of the learning activity.
Ask participants: "How do we recognise emotions when we can only see someone's face on a screen?"
The turning point could happen when Mark notices a change in Anna's facial expression or when Elena sends a private supportive message to Anna or Mark before speaking to the group.
The debrief can take place in the main meeting room or through a collaborative digital board where participants can contribute anonymous written reflections.
The Communication Checklist can be created in a shared online document.
