EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 06

Ethical Leadership

Explore integrity, fairness, responsibility and ethical decision-making through realistic leadership dilemmas and group situations.

Module 6 was developed by TDM 2000, Italy, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 1 / 5

SCENARIO 1

THE POPULAR VOLUNTEER

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

The Popular Volunteer

Module Association

Module 6 – Ethical Leadership

Module Theme

Fair Selection, Transparency and Ethical Decision-Making

Competencies Developed

Fairness; Transparency; Ethical Decision-Making

Target Audience

Young people aged 15–18 years; Youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

10–15 minutes for the role-play; 15–20 minutes for the debrief

Difficulty Level

Intermediate

Format

In-person, online or blended

Learning Objectives

Explore how leaders make fair decisions when resources are limited.
Recognise the impact of favoritism, whether intentional or unintentional.
Practise communicating difficult decisions transparently and respectfully.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION

A youth organisation has received funding to send one participant to an international youth exchange programme.

Several young people are interested in the opportunity.

Alex is well-known, charismatic and popular within the group. He regularly participates in visible activities and has strong relationships with staff members.

Sara is quieter but has consistently contributed behind the scenes and has attended almost every activity throughout the year.

The youth leader must recommend one participant for the exchange.

Some group members assume that Alex will be selected, while others believe that Sara deserves the opportunity.

The decision must be made quickly and communicated publicly.

The scenario explores fairness, transparency and how ethical leaders balance relationships, expectations and objective criteria.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: YOUTH LEADER

Profile of the Character

The youth leader is responsible for selecting one participant for the exchange programme. They value fairness and want to make a transparent decision based on clear criteria.

Emotional State

Concerned about making the right choice and worried about disappointing either Alex or Sara.

Motivation

The youth leader wants to make the best decision for the group and select a suitable participant.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The youth leader hopes to avoid conflict whilst maintaining trust and credibility. They also fear that their decision, whatever it is, could disappoint part of the group.

ROLE 2: ALEX

Profile of the Character

Alex is charismatic, confident and enjoys being in the spotlight. He assumes he will be selected because of his popularity and visibility.

Emotional State

Confident but potentially defensive if not selected.

Motivation

Alex wants to represent the organisation internationally.

Goal / Hidden Intention

Alex assumes he is the obvious choice. He fears losing his status in the group if he is not selected.

ROLE 3: SARA

Profile of the Character

Sara is a quiet but highly committed participant who contributes consistently behind the scenes.

Emotional State

Hopeful, anxious and undervalued.

Motivation

Sara wants her effort and commitment to be recognised.

Goal / Hidden Intention

Sara believes she deserves the opportunity but struggles to advocate for herself.

She worries that visibility and popularity matter more than consistent contribution.

ROLE 4: PEER GROUP REPRESENTATIVE

Profile of the Character

The peer group representative communicates the concerns and opinions of the other participants.

Emotional State

Curious and concerned about fairness.

Motivation

The representative wants transparency in the selection process.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The representative hopes the final decision will not divide the group.

They want the youth leader to explain the criteria clearly.

D. ACTIVITY FLOW

STEP 1: PREPARATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Introduce the opportunity and distribute the role cards. Participants review their roles, emotional states and objectives.

Time: 5 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Emphasise that the goal is not to find one universally "correct" answer, but to explore ethical decision-making. Remind participants that popularity, visibility and contribution are not always the same.

STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY

Facilitation / Activity Step: The youth leader meets with Alex, Sara and the peer group representative before announcing the final decision. Participants discuss expectations, contributions, selection criteria and concerns.

Time: 10–15 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Encourage participants to defend their perspectives authentically. The youth leader may decide to select one candidate, delay the decision until criteria are agreed, or propose a more transparent process.

STEP 3: OBSERVATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Optional observers track references to fairness, transparency, contribution and emotional reactions.

Time: During the role-play

Notes for Facilitator: Observers should note moments when relationships, visibility, assumptions or biases influence the decision.

STEP 4: DEBRIEF AND REFLECTION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Facilitate a discussion using the reflection questions.

Time: 15–20 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Explore how fairness and transparency influence trust. Discuss whether a fair process always produces a result that everyone considers fair.

STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE

Facilitation / Activity Step: Participants develop a set of principles for fair selection processes in youth organisations.

Time: 5–10 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Connect the learning to real opportunities such as youth exchanges, training courses, internships, school trips and leadership roles.

Possible principles include:

  • publish criteria before applications open;
  • use the same criteria for every candidate;
  • involve more than one person in the decision;
  • document the reasons for the decision;
  • provide feedback to unsuccessful applicants;
  • declare possible conflicts of interest.

E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS

How did you feel in your role?
What factors should a leader consider to ensure a fair decision?
How did transparency influence trust in the leader's decision?
How can leaders avoid favoritism while maintaining positive relationships within a group?

F. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Printed or digital role cards
  • Observer sheet
  • Flipchart or digital whiteboard
  • Pens and paper
  • Timer

G. ADAPTATION NOTES

Adaptation for Different Groups

For younger participants, use a school trip, camp or sports team opportunity.

For older participants, use an internship, Erasmus+ mobility, training course or youth exchange selection.

Cultural and Local Adaptation

Replace the youth exchange with a locally relevant opportunity.

Adapt the selection criteria to the type of activity.

Accessibility Considerations

Use simplified role cards and allow participants to observe instead of taking an active role.

Provide the selection criteria in writing.

Allow extra preparation time where needed.

Online Delivery Version

Conduct the selection discussion in a breakout room.

Observers can track the decision-making process using a shared online form.

The group can create its fair selection principles on a collaborative digital board.