EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 06

Ethical Leadership

Explore integrity, fairness, responsibility and ethical decision-making through realistic leadership dilemmas and group situations.

Module 6 was developed by TDM 2000, Italy, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 3 / 5

SCENARIO 3

THE NEWCOMER

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

The Newcomer

Module Association

Module 6 – Ethical Leadership

Module Theme

Inclusion, empathy and ethical responsibility towards others

Competences Developed

Inclusive leadership; empathy; social awareness; communication; ethical responsibility

Target Group

Young people aged 15–18; youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

10–15 minutes for role-play; 15–20 minutes for debrief

Difficulty Level

Intermediate

Format

Face-to-face, online or blended

Learning Objectives

Recognise signs that a new participant is being unintentionally excluded.
Explore the ethical responsibility of leaders and group members to create belonging.
Practise inclusive leadership and peer-support strategies.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION

A new participant joins a local youth group halfway through the year.

Most group members already know each other well and have established friendships.

During meetings and activities, conversations naturally happen within existing friendship circles.

Although nobody openly rejects the newcomer, invitations, inside jokes and informal discussions often happen without including them.

Over time, the newcomer becomes quieter and less engaged.

A peer leader begins to notice the situation and wonders whether to intervene.

Another group member also notices the exclusion but is uncertain whether it is their responsibility to act.

The scenario explores inclusion, empathy and the ethical responsibility that leaders and group members have to ensure that everyone feels valued and welcomed.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: NEW PARTICIPANT

Profile of the Character

The new participant recently joined the group and does not know anyone well.

Emotional State

Nervous, isolated and discouraged.

Motivation

The newcomer wants to belong and participate.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The newcomer hopes someone will notice their discomfort.

They do not want to complain or appear overly dependent.

ROLE 2: PEER LEADER

Profile of the Character

The peer leader is responsible for supporting group participation and engagement.

Emotional State

Concerned and empathetic.

Motivation

The peer leader wants everyone to feel included.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The peer leader is looking for a way to intervene without blaming the established group or making the newcomer feel exposed.

ROLE 3: ESTABLISHED GROUP MEMBER

Profile of the Character

The established group member is friendly but focused mainly on existing friendships.

Emotional State

Comfortable and unaware.

Motivation

The participant wants to enjoy the activity with friends.

Goal / Hidden Intention

They do not realise that inside jokes, closed seating arrangements and informal conversations are excluding the newcomer.

ROLE 4: OBSERVING GROUP MEMBER

Profile of the Character

This group member notices the group dynamics but rarely speaks up.

Emotional State

Uncertain and conflicted.

Motivation

The participant wants harmony within the group.

Goal / Hidden Intention

They are unsure whether it is their responsibility to act or whether intervention may make the situation more uncomfortable.

D. ACTIVITY FLOW

STEP 1: PREPARATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Introduce the situation and distribute the role cards. Give participants time to think about body language, seating, eye contact and informal communication.

Time: 5 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Explain that exclusion is often unintentional. The activity should not involve direct bullying or obvious hostility.

STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY

Facilitation / Activity Step: The group prepares for an upcoming activity while the newcomer attempts to participate. The established group member focuses on familiar friends. The observing member and peer leader notice the newcomer's increasing withdrawal and decide whether and how to respond.

Time: 10–15 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Encourage realistic interactions. Allow the exclusion to emerge through small behaviours rather than explicit rejection.

STEP 3: OBSERVATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Optional observers track participation opportunities and non-verbal cues.

Time: During the role-play

Notes for Facilitator: Observers should pay attention to:

  • who speaks;
  • who receives eye contact;
  • who is invited to join;
  • who is ignored;
  • whether seating or inside jokes create barriers;
  • when the newcomer begins to withdraw.

STEP 4: DEBRIEF AND REFLECTION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Discuss feelings of belonging, responsibility and inclusion.

Time: 15–20 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Encourage participants to reflect from each role's perspective. Explore the difference between being friendly in general and actively including someone.

STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE

Facilitation / Activity Step: Develop inclusion strategies for future youth activities.

Time: 5–10 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Focus on practical actions that leaders and group members can take.

Examples include:

  • welcoming new participants personally;
  • explaining inside references;
  • using rotating pairs or groups;
  • introducing a buddy system;
  • inviting rather than pressuring someone to speak;
  • checking in privately;
  • explaining unwritten group rules;
  • avoiding closed friendship circles during activities.

E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS

How did the newcomer experience the group's behaviour?
What signs suggested that someone was feeling excluded?
What responsibility do leaders and group members have in creating an inclusive environment?
What practical actions could help newcomers feel welcomed and involved?

F. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Printed or digital role cards
  • Observer sheet
  • Chairs arranged in a circle
  • Flipchart or digital board
  • Markers
  • Timer

G. ADAPTATION NOTES

Adaptation for Different Groups

For younger groups, use a school club, sports team or after-school activity.

For older groups, use a volunteer programme, youth organisation, university society or workplace team.

Cultural and Local Adaptation

Adapt the setting to a relevant local youth activity.

The newcomer may have joined because of relocation, migration, a school change or personal interest.

Accessibility Considerations

Allow participants to observe if role-play feels uncomfortable.

Use clear written instructions and visual cues.

Do not ask participants to describe personal experiences of exclusion unless they choose to do so.

Online Delivery Version

Simulate exclusion and inclusion dynamics during a video call.

The newcomer may be ignored in the chat, left outside an informal online group or not invited into a breakout-room conversation.

The group can create an online newcomer-welcome checklist after the activity.