EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 06

Ethical Leadership

Explore integrity, fairness, responsibility and ethical decision-making through realistic leadership dilemmas and group situations.

Module 6 was developed by TDM 2000, Italy, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 5 / 5

SCENARIO 5

THE SPONSOR'S REQUEST

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

The Sponsor's Request

Module Association

Module 6 – Ethical Leadership

Module Theme

Values-based leadership, inclusion and ethical decision-making under pressure

Competences Developed

Values-based leadership; inclusion; ethical decision-making; negotiation; accountability; sustainability

Target Group

Young people aged 18–21; youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

15–20 minutes for role-play; approximately 20 minutes for debrief

Difficulty Level

Advanced

Format

Face-to-face, online or blended

Learning Objectives

Explore conflicts between organisational values and external pressures.
Practise making decisions based on ethical principles.
Understand how leaders balance sustainability and inclusion.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION

A youth organisation is preparing a promotional campaign to attract future participants and secure funding for its programmes.

A local sponsor offers significant financial support but requests that only the most successful and high-achieving participants be featured in the campaign materials.

The sponsor argues that highlighting outstanding achievements will attract more attention and strengthen the organisation's reputation.

The project team believes that all participants should be represented, including those who have faced challenges and experienced personal growth rather than measurable success.

One participant who benefited greatly from the programme would be excluded under the sponsor's proposed criteria.

Without the funding, several planned activities may need to be reduced or cancelled.

The leadership team must decide whether to accept the sponsor's conditions, negotiate an alternative solution or refuse the offer.

The scenario explores values-based leadership, inclusion and ethical decision-making under pressure.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: PROJECT LEADER

Profile of the Character

The project leader is responsible for securing funding and protecting the organisation's values.

Emotional State

Pressured and conflicted.

Motivation

The project leader wants both financial stability and ethical integrity.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The leader is searching for a solution that protects the organisation's values while keeping planned activities financially possible.

ROLE 2: SPONSOR REPRESENTATIVE

Profile of the Character

The representative speaks on behalf of the organisation offering financial support.

Emotional State

Confident and pragmatic.

Motivation

The representative wants a strong and attractive promotional campaign.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The representative believes that visible success stories are the most effective marketing strategy.

They are focused on measurable outcomes and public reputation.

ROLE 3: PARTICIPANT AT RISK OF EXCLUSION

Profile of the Character

This participant benefited greatly from the programme despite facing significant personal challenges.

Their progress is meaningful but may not appear as a traditional high-achievement success story.

Emotional State

Hurt, disappointed and insecure.

Motivation

The participant wants all participants and forms of progress to be valued equally.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The participant wants the organisation's leaders to remain true to their stated principles.

They fear that accepting the sponsor's request will communicate that only exceptional achievement has value.

ROLE 4: TEAM MEMBER

Profile of the Character

The team member is focused on ensuring that future projects and activities can continue.

Emotional State

Concerned and practical.

Motivation

The team member wants the funding to be secured.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The team member believes some compromise may be necessary for financial sustainability.

They worry that refusing the offer may harm many future participants.

D. ACTIVITY FLOW

STEP 1: PREPARATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Introduce the funding dilemma and distribute the role cards. Participants identify the main values, needs and risks connected to their role.

Time: 5 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Emphasise that every position contains legitimate concerns. The sponsor should not be portrayed as entirely unethical, and the team member should not be portrayed as caring only about money.

STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY

Facilitation / Activity Step: The project team meets with the sponsor representative to discuss the campaign proposal and decide how to respond. Participants may accept the conditions, refuse them or negotiate an alternative.

Time: 15–20 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Encourage negotiation rather than immediate acceptance or rejection. Possible alternatives may include presenting several definitions of success, combining achievement with personal-growth stories or agreeing on shared campaign principles.

STEP 3: OBSERVATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Optional observers track references to values, inclusion, financial sustainability, power and compromise.

Time: During the role-play

Notes for Facilitator: Observers should note how participants justify their decisions and whose voice has the most influence.

STEP 4: DEBRIEF AND REFLECTION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Discuss ethical trade-offs and leadership responsibility.

Time: Approximately 20 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Explore how values influence decision-making under pressure. Discuss whether compromise is always a betrayal of values or whether it can sometimes protect them.

STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE

Facilitation / Activity Step: Participants identify organisational values they would not compromise and develop strategies for protecting them.

Time: 5–10 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Connect the learning to future leadership roles, community initiatives, sponsorships and partnerships.

Possible protective strategies include:

  • creating an ethical sponsorship policy;
  • defining non-negotiable values;
  • discussing expectations before accepting funding;
  • including ethical clauses in agreements;
  • diversifying funding sources;
  • ensuring participant consent;
  • involving affected participants in decisions;
  • communicating transparently with stakeholders.

E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS

What values were in conflict during this situation?
How did the pressure to secure funding affect the decision-making process?
Was there a solution that balanced both the sponsor's expectations and the organisation's values?
What should leaders do when external pressures challenge their ethical principles?

F. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Printed or digital role cards
  • Observer sheet
  • Flipchart or digital whiteboard
  • Pens and paper
  • Optional campaign proposal
  • Optional ethical sponsorship principles template
  • Timer

G. ADAPTATION NOTES

Adaptation for Different Groups

For younger participants, simplify the financial aspects and use a smaller sponsorship decision, such as funding for a school or youth-club event.

For older participants, include specific budget figures, cancellation risks and pressure from several stakeholders.

Cultural and Local Adaptation

Replace the sponsor with a locally relevant organisation, company, public institution or donor.

Adapt the promotional campaign and types of achievement to the local context.

Accessibility Considerations

Provide simplified summaries of the funding dilemma.

Present the key choices visually.

Allow written contributions and extra preparation time.

Online Delivery Version

Conduct negotiations in breakout rooms.

Groups can present their final decision and ethical justification to the full group.

A collaborative board can be used to compare which values each group considered non-negotiable.

DISCLAIMER

Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are, however, those of the author or authors only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Education and Culture Executive Agency (EACEA). Neither the European Union nor EACEA can be held responsible for them.