EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 06

Ethical Leadership

Explore integrity, fairness, responsibility and ethical decision-making through realistic leadership dilemmas and group situations.

Module 6 was developed by TDM 2000, Italy, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 2 / 5

SCENARIO 2

THE TEAM PROJECT CREDIT

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

The Team Project Credit

Module Association

Module 6 – Ethical Leadership

Module Theme

Integrity, accountability and fair recognition of contributions

Competences Developed

Integrity; accountability; recognition of contributions

Target Group

Young people aged 15–18; youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

10–15 minutes for role-play; 15–20 minutes for debrief

Difficulty Level

Intermediate

Format

Face-to-face, online or blended

Learning Objectives

Understand the importance of recognising collective effort.
Explore leadership responsibility when credit is distributed unfairly.
Practise addressing ethical issues constructively.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION

A group of young people has spent several weeks developing a community project.

During a public presentation attended by teachers, parents and local stakeholders, Daniel delivers the final speech.

As he speaks, he focuses mainly on his own efforts and achievements and gives little recognition to the work completed by the other team members.

Some participants feel frustrated and disappointed.

Others are unsure whether the situation is serious enough to address.

The team leader worked extensively on the project but received almost no public recognition.

The project coordinator notices the tension but hesitates to intervene during the event.

After the presentation, the team gathers to discuss what happened.

The scenario examines accountability, integrity and how leaders can ensure that recognition is distributed fairly.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: DANIEL

Profile of the Character

Daniel is a confident presenter who naturally takes leadership roles and is comfortable speaking publicly.

Emotional State

Proud, enthusiastic and initially unaware.

Motivation

Daniel wants recognition for the project's success.

Goal / Hidden Intention

Daniel does not realise that he is overshadowing the other team members.

He believes that his public-speaking role means he is representing the whole team.

ROLE 2: TEAM LEADER

Profile of the Character

The team leader worked extensively on the project but received little recognition during the public presentation.

Emotional State

Frustrated, disappointed and angry.

Motivation

The team leader wants contributions to be acknowledged fairly.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The team leader wants Daniel to understand the impact of his actions.

They are also worried that confronting him may damage the team atmosphere.

ROLE 3: PROJECT COORDINATOR

Profile of the Character

The project coordinator oversees the activity and supports the team.

Emotional State

Concerned and conflicted.

Motivation

The coordinator wants to maintain team cohesion and protect the integrity of the project.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The coordinator is unsure whether they should have intervened publicly or whether the issue should be addressed privately after the event.

ROLE 4: OBSERVER PEER

Profile of the Character

The observer peer witnessed both the presentation and the team's working process.

Emotional State

Neutral but attentive.

Motivation

The observer wants fairness and a positive team atmosphere.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The observer may encourage dialogue and help the team distinguish between Daniel's intention and the impact of his presentation.

D. ACTIVITY FLOW

STEP 1: PREPARATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Explain the situation and distribute the role cards. Participants think about their character's contribution to the project and reaction to the presentation.

Time: 5 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Remind participants to consider intentions as well as outcomes. The activity is not about humiliating Daniel, but about accountability and repair.

STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY

Facilitation / Activity Step: The team meets after the public presentation. Participants discuss what happened, how recognition was distributed and what should be done next.

Time: 10–15 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Allow emotions to emerge naturally. Encourage participants to propose both immediate and longer-term responses.

STEP 3: OBSERVATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Optional observers track examples of accountability, defensiveness, active listening and repair.

Time: During the role-play

Notes for Facilitator: Observers should note how participants respond to criticism and whether the team distinguishes between intention and impact.

STEP 4: DEBRIEF AND REFLECTION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Explore perceptions of fairness, recognition and leadership responsibility.

Time: 15–20 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Discuss how leaders and presenters can share credit without minimising their own contribution.

STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE

Facilitation / Activity Step: Participants create guidelines for recognising contributions in group projects.

Time: 5–10 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Connect the activity to school, volunteering, university, community and workplace contexts.

Possible guidelines include:

  • agree in advance who will present each section;
  • name all contributors;
  • recognise both visible and behind-the-scenes work;
  • review speeches before public presentations;
  • correct incomplete recognition publicly when appropriate;
  • document tasks and responsibilities throughout the project.

E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS

How did the team members feel when recognition was distributed unevenly?
Do you think Daniel intended to be unfair? Why or why not?
What responsibility does a leader have to acknowledge the contributions of others?

F. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Printed or digital role cards
  • Observer sheet
  • Flipchart or digital whiteboard
  • Timer

G. ADAPTATION NOTES

Adaptation for Different Groups

For younger groups, use a school project or sports-team presentation.

For older groups, use a community initiative, university project or public campaign.

Cultural and Local Adaptation

Adapt the project topic and public event to local community needs.

The presentation could take place at a school, municipality, youth centre or community festival.

Accessibility Considerations

Provide role summaries in plain language.

Allow written contributions during the role-play.

Participants who do not want to act may observe the distribution of speaking time and recognition.

Online Delivery Version

Use a virtual project presentation followed by breakout-room discussions.

Participants may review a fictional presentation script and identify whose contributions were acknowledged or omitted.