EmLeadWP4
Repository

EMLEAD · Work Package 4 · 06

Ethical Leadership

Explore integrity, fairness, responsibility and ethical decision-making through realistic leadership dilemmas and group situations.

Module 6 was developed by TDM 2000, Italy, as part of the EMLEAD project.

Scenario 4 / 5

SCENARIO 4

THE RUMOUR IN THE GROUP CHAT

A. SCENARIO OVERVIEW

Scenario Title

The Rumour in the Group Chat

Module Association

Module 6 – Ethical Leadership

Module Theme

Digital ethics, courage and responsible leadership

Competences Developed

Ethical decision-making; digital citizenship; empathy; courage; responsible communication; bystander responsibility

Target Group

Young people aged 15–18; youth workers and facilitators in training

Duration

10–15 minutes for role-play; 15–20 minutes for debrief

Difficulty Level

Intermediate

Format

Face-to-face, online or blended

Learning Objectives

Understand the ethical responsibilities of leaders and group members in digital spaces.
Explore the role of silent observers when harmful online behaviour occurs.
Practise responding to rumours, screenshots and harmful jokes responsibly.
Recognise that online actions can have serious offline consequences.

B. CONTEXT DESCRIPTION

A rumour about a member of a youth group begins circulating in a private messaging group.

Some participants share screenshots and jokes connected to the rumour.

Others read the messages without responding.

The person at the centre of the rumour is initially unaware of the discussion.

As the conversation continues, the atmosphere becomes increasingly uncomfortable.

A youth leader eventually notices the messages and must decide how to respond.

Some participants argue that it is only a joke, while others believe the behaviour is harmful.

The target later learns about the conversation and feels hurt, embarrassed and betrayed.

The scenario explores ethical leadership in digital spaces and the responsibility of individuals who witness harmful behaviour online.

C. ROLES

ROLE 1: YOUTH LEADER

Profile of the Character

The youth leader is responsible for maintaining a safe group environment, including online spaces connected to the group.

Emotional State

Concerned and responsible.

Motivation

The youth leader wants to stop the harmful behaviour and support the affected participant.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The leader hopes to address the issue without escalating conflict or publicly humiliating anyone.

They must also decide whether individual, group or formal action is necessary.

ROLE 2: PARTICIPANT SHARING THE RUMOUR

Profile of the Character

This participant actively contributes to the discussion by forwarding messages, sharing screenshots and adding jokes.

Emotional State

Amused at first and defensive when challenged.

Motivation

The participant wants social approval and attention from peers.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The participant believes the content is harmless entertainment.

They want to avoid responsibility by saying that everyone was participating.

ROLE 3: SILENT OBSERVER

Profile of the Character

The silent observer reads the messages but does not react or intervene.

Emotional State

Uncomfortable and hesitant.

Motivation

The observer wants to avoid conflict and attention.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The observer is unsure whether silence makes them responsible.

They are afraid of becoming the next target if they challenge the group.

ROLE 4: TARGET OF THE RUMOUR

Profile of the Character

The participant learns about the private discussion later.

Emotional State

Hurt, embarrassed and betrayed.

Motivation

The participant wants respect, safety and understanding.

Goal / Hidden Intention

The participant wants others to recognise the impact of their actions.

They also want the rumour and screenshots to stop spreading.

D. ACTIVITY FLOW

STEP 1: PREPARATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Explain the scenario and distribute the role cards. Participants review the fictional group-chat situation and their role's perspective.

Time: 5 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Remind participants that online actions have real consequences. Use only fictional and non-sensitive examples.

STEP 2: ROLE-PLAY

Facilitation / Activity Step: Participants simulate the development of the group-chat rumour and the discussion that follows after the youth leader and target become aware of it. The group must decide how to stop the rumour, support the target and address responsibility.

Time: 10–15 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Encourage realistic online and offline reactions. Do not require participants to invent detailed personal rumours. Focus on the communication and ethical dilemma.

STEP 3: OBSERVATION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Optional observers track moments when intervention could have occurred.

Time: During the role-play

Notes for Facilitator: Observers should identify barriers that prevented people from speaking up and note the effects of silence, emojis, forwarding and screenshots.

STEP 4: DEBRIEF AND REFLECTION

Facilitation / Activity Step: Discuss digital responsibility, privacy, courage and bystander behaviour.

Time: 15–20 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Explore the role of courage in ethical leadership. Discuss the difference between stopping harm, punishing people and repairing relationships.

STEP 5: TRANSFER TO PRACTICE

Facilitation / Activity Step: Create group principles for respectful online communication and intervention.

Time: 5–10 minutes

Notes for Facilitator: Connect the principles to digital environments used by participants.

Possible principles include:

  • do not forward unverified personal information;
  • do not share screenshots without consent;
  • challenge harmful messages safely;
  • report serious behaviour to a responsible adult or moderator;
  • privately support the targeted person;
  • delete harmful content;
  • avoid treating silence as approval;
  • agree on group-chat rules in advance.

E. REFLECTION QUESTIONS

What responsibility do leaders and group members have in creating an inclusive environment?
What role did the silent observers play in the situation?
Why can it be difficult to challenge harmful behaviour online?

F. MATERIALS NEEDED

  • Printed or digital role cards
  • Fictional group-chat screenshots
  • Observer sheet
  • Flipchart or digital board
  • Group-chat principles template
  • Timer

G. ADAPTATION NOTES

Adaptation for Different Groups

For younger groups, use a fictional school-class chat.

For older groups, use a youth project, university or volunteering group chat.

Cultural and Local Adaptation

Use the most common messaging platform in the local context.

Adapt moderation and reporting options to the platform used.

Accessibility Considerations

Avoid sensitive personal topics that may directly affect participants.

Use short fictional chat messages and plain language.

Participants may contribute through writing instead of acting.

Online Delivery Version

Use a mock chat discussion in a shared online space.

The facilitator should ensure that the simulated content remains fictional and respectful.

The final online-safety principles can be created collaboratively.